5 ms·
Our Open-Plan Office Failed, So We’re Moving to a Towering Panopticon
- protomyth 9y agoThis one would be pretty vile, but I bet we have folks who seen just as bad. I once worked at a place that once powered their campus by an oil burning generator. They stored the oil in a large underground bunker. The bunker was a concrete affair. Eventually the oil plant was decommissioned and the bunker was cleaned up. Some [censored] person decided they needed more office space and this bunker would be great. They completed the tunnel from a nearby building (they had a large underground) and proceeded to build a false floor and put in a box for offices. Now, concrete will "bleed" oil for a while even if sealed, so the solution to that was install fans that would push fresh air between the office area wall and the concrete wall. Inside their new space, they put a cube farm. Sadly, cellphones and radios didn't work in the new space as it was underground with a nice reinforced (rebar) concrete roof. Having a constant wind noise in a cube underground is a bit surreal.
- otakucode 9y agoProbably would actually be marginally less destructive to productivity than open floor plan offices. But still a childish fit to throw just to avoid saving mountains of money by cancelling the office lease and having everyone work from home.
- yarrel 9y agoOur Incredibly Self-Regarding Smugness Is Also Available In Dead Tree Format In A Way That Looks Like An Inheritance Being Burned.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Animats 9y agoThere are probably jobs where there's someone watching a split-screen display showing the webcam images of all their subordinates. (IoT idea: Desktop USB activated food reward dispenser. Boss-controlled.) (Just checked. It's available. Pavlov Treat Dispenser $69.95 [1]) [1] http://pavlovdogmonitor.com/treat-dispenser/pavlov-treat-dispenser http://pavlovdogmonitor.com/treat-dispenser/pavlov-treat-dis...)
- protomyth 9y agoThere are probably jobs where there's someone watching a split-screen display showing the webcam images of all their subordinates. A whole lot of daycares do this. A proper security system will keep the footage for a month. At least the treat dispenser is advertised for use with the dog, but I bet if someone handed you this document cold with actual letterhead, it might take a bit of reading to realize the parody.
- Animats 9y agoIf someone handed you the device, you'd think it was for humans. It looks more like a desktop device than a dog feeder. Maybe it was originally designed for the education market.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoEvery accepted pull request gets you a chocolate... hooked up to Github webhooks.
- pizza 9y agoYou could mandate Pavloks be worn at work to receive compensation. Then just hook them up to a punishment API! (groan) Why give out expensive and forgettable treats, when you could use the much more persistent memory of a painful shock, using the sense of pain that comes built-into the employee?
- candiodari 9y agoProbably works best when combined with other pavlovian employee management tools: https://goo.gl/f9iNVN https://goo.gl/f9iNVN And of course, there may be complaints. Luckily that too can be solved by management innovations ! https://goo.gl/wrKDke https://goo.gl/wrKDke
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoHonestly, I think I'd prefer the physical structure of a Panopticon to the "Warehouse" style open offices that exist today (it would certainly be quieter). Some of these were actually built - here's a neat overview of some in Cuba - http://weburbanist.com/2014/05/15/real-life-panopticons-deserted-dystopian-prisons-in-cuba/ http://weburbanist.com/2014/05/15/real-life-panopticons-dese...
- trhway 9y agoAs the open-floor plan is already basically a Panopticon - with the director in his office with a glass wall through which he directly overlooks us in the open-floor area, and the manager just at the strategic table (his back to the window, face overlooking our team) adding any "cell" walls would be a vast improvement (which also would result in improvement for lighting (limiting direct Sun hitting eyes/monitor), AC and ventilation (better turbulence/mixing before cold/fresh air just rivers away like it does in the open-floor) and thus less virus spreading effects, etc...) The new Apple "spaceship" building would have "pods" so depending on how field of view is organized there it may be kind of Panopticon.
- Animats 9y agoBanks used to do that explicitly. The managers sat on a raised platform, in the open, overlooking the tellers and banking floor. Some bank branches still have a raised platform.
- elil17 9y agoIt should be noted these panopticons were built by Machado, the dictator who Castro rebelled against.
- nerfhammer 9y agoWeirdly it feels like it would be more embarrassing sitting in the tower rather than one of the cells. The person in the tower can only look at a few cells at a time but hundreds of people in the cells will be staring at the tower all the time.
- mcguire 9y agoPoor Daniel Finch.
- gozur88 9y ago>So Synergon is really better than the current open-plan office? Sadly, it really is.
- WhatIsDukkha 9y agoYou know what is worse then the open office plan? The fact that large numbers of people loathe it and yet do nothing about it except moan on the internet. People don't organize themselves and their coworkers to even ask for better things.
- unionstrong 9y agoYou ever try organizing a bunch of 20-somethings who make $90,000 per year and buy food from robot bodegas? You'd have better luck getting RMS to use Windows.
- yahna 9y agoah yes, it's the 20-somethings. It's always the 20-somethings.
- unionstrong 9y agoI'm making a point. Software developers, for some reason (maybe it's the pay, the benefits, the mobility, the ignorance of history, or some combination thereof), seem very resistant to organizing. It's easier to complain than be the only person in your office seen as a problem because you're fighting against some trendy, money-saving bullshit.
- unionstrong 9y agoAlso, I'm a 20-something, so...
- watwut 9y agoOpen office is bad for general productivity of all, but organizing against it is bad specifically for your own career and salary. Good negotiators tend to go for their own salaries, interesting projects, better positions etc etc etc while pushing against open office (or other popular corporate must have) makes their position for the above weaker. Anonymous venting is safer and feels good. Now you know.
- 9y ago
- chriskanan 9y agoWhat's a good way to make an open office more tolerable? My lab is a large rectangular room filled with desks and computers. I don't really have enough space to make cubicles, and I can't get more space. I'd love to improve the work space for my researchers. Right now my lab is basically 3 rows of desks in an open office plan, with probably 6 people there on average, but closer to 10 during summers.
- bhhaskin 9y agoThanks for posting this! What a great and fun read!