4 ms·
Last year, it was the Interplanetary Transport System, but now Musk has regressed to using the original, cheeky "code name" BFR, in which the B stands for big,
by kbenson 9y ago
Last year, it was the Interplanetary Transport System, but now Musk has regressed to using the original, cheeky "code name" BFR, in which the B stands for big, the R stands for rocket, and the F stands for fun. (Not really).
I'm always astounded that apparently we still can't say fuck lest some bogeyman (real or imaginary) jump out and make you regret it.
It's a fucking word. For fuck's sake. I mean, at the point where it's used more often as garnish in it's various adverb and noun forms than it's original verb form, you know, to fuck, how bad can it really be and why do we need to penalize the usage so?
Now watch this get auto-depressed by HN's incendiary comment detection filters.
Edit: If you see this reach the top, please downvote or unvote. I'm interested in this topic, but it doesn't deserve to overshadow real discussion about the submission.
- stcredzero 9y agoF stands for fun. (Not really). F does stand for fun. A lot of it. It's really down to attitude.
- ericjang 9y agoIs this an American cultural thing, or are other cultures just as averse to public swearing?
- saalweachter 9y agoIt's not particularly more professional to cheekily use an obvious substitute in place of 'fucking', either. If you are saying "big ... fun ... rocket" or "big freakin' rocket" anyone over the age of 6 will know what you are doing and, if they are inclined to feel uncomfortable or offended, will still be so. So for the most part I would say "either swear or don't", but if you are going to play that game, you need to be better at it, and call it something like "a big functional rocket" or "a big futuristic rocket", which is plausible, and then remain completely straight-faced, forever, never admitting in public or private there could be any other meaning for the acronym, ever. Leave historians a hundred years from now guessing. "Wink wink, I'm not cussing!!!" is just another version of "I'm not touching you!!!".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- YaxelPerez 9y agoBig Falcon Rocket?
- fnord123 9y agoIt's largely an American thing.
- toephu2 9y agoFalse. The Japanese language itself doesn't really have any swear words let alone the culture being averse to using any swear words in public.
- fnord123 9y agoGP asked if only Americans are averse to swearing. Japanese don't have swearing so they're not averse to it. So this is not a counterexample as far as I can see.
- baq 9y agoTaboo and forbidden words apparently exist in all human cultures. There are a few other things, too, and some things that you could expect to be there are missing :) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_universal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_universal
- toephu2 9y agoThere aren't any real swear words in Japanese. So no it's not just an American thing.
- hacking_again 9y agoHow do you explain this? http://www.youswear.com/index.asp?language=Japanese http://www.youswear.com/index.asp?language=Japanese
- toephu2 9y agoFakku? That's a transliteration from English. Most Japanese speakers generally agree that Japanese doesn't "really" have any of its own swear words. Yes if you get technical there are some like those listed on that site, but generally there are not, it is a very polite language.
- hacking_again 9y agoTry calling your female Japanese friends "manko" and see if you still have female Japanese friends.
- toephu2 9y agoPlease see my above comment. "generally agree" and "Yes if you get technical there are some" and "but generally there are not" You just picked out one example. That defies my definition of generally?
- hacking_again 9y agoIn my experience the public face of Japanese society is very polite, but that's distinct from what can be said with the language, and what people say with the language in private face contexts. It also varies to some degree by class, but you could say the same thing about English. Also, loanwords like fakku are a legitimate part of the language. The katakana script is used almost exclusively for them and many sentences have them, spoken and written.
- yahna 9y agoAmericans love violence but sex and swearing is evil horrible stuff.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yathern 9y agoAnything can be trivialized if you detest social norms enough. Fake examples: > It took me forever to find a good font for my webcomic that wasn't comic sans. I'm astounded that apparently we can't use a perfects good font, lest some bogeyman jump out and make you regret it. It's a font! For Microsoft Bob's sake. How bad can it really be and why do we need to penalize the usage so? > John Smith, 56, was arrested for indecent exposure in a playground while laughing maniacally. I'm astounded that apparently we can't show our entire bodies in public lest some bogeyman jump out and make you regret it. It's a body part. I mean, it's how all other animals live - how bad can it really be and why do we need to penalize the usage so? > Riots ensue as it is leaked that all Burger King meat has been human meat, this whole time. I'm astounded that apparently we can't eat human meat lest some bogeyman jump out and make you regret it. It's meat! For meat's sake. I mean, at the point where a human is dead, why can't we eat the meat? How bad can it really be and why do we need to penalize the usage so?
- kbenson 9y agoTo be clear, the difference I'm calling out here is not that the cutural norm is stupid, but that it's only enforced in specific contexts for no apparent gain. I wouldn't say a large proportion of people are walking around in public naked, but a large proportion do swear in the course of normal speaking. Really, it's the news agencies which are the worst offenders in this regard, which is doubly bad because they will actually sacrifice clarity and accuracy to avoid these words. [1][2][3] Try searching for "cock" in any of the referenced articles. What does that achieve? 1: http://www.cnn.com/2017/07/31/politics/anthony-scaramucci/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2017/07/31/politics/anthony-scaramucci/in... 2: http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/07/27/anthony-scaramucci-uses-vulgar-language-to-lash-out-at-priebus-make-fun-bannon-in-interview.html http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2017/07/27/anthony-scaramucc... 3: http://variety.com/2017/biz/news/anthony-scaramucci-steve-bannon-reince-priebus-1202508936/ http://variety.com/2017/biz/news/anthony-scaramucci-steve-ba...
- yathern 9y agoI totally get your opinion that language should be used more freely. But at the end of the day - different things are appropriate in different contexts. Some of these we feel strongly about, others, we may not. > A bathing suit is not considered appropriate at a wedding. > Emoji is not considered appropriate at a funeral. > White pants are not considered appropriate after Labor Day. > Swearing is not considered appropriate in certain styles of journalism. All of these, when viewed at a low enough level of abstraction (we're all just atoms!) make no sense. But that doesn't mean we should do away with them all.
- jff 9y agoThey presumably call it the Big Fucking Rocket at SpaceX. But if Musk says "Big Fucking Rocket" on stage, TV news can't quote him. That's counterproductive to his goals, but using a heavy implication both allows him a broader audience and lets every adult know they've got the 'cheeky' name for it.
- Osmium 9y agoIt's a big world out there, and we're all just trying to get along. I'm not in the least bit offended by swearing and swear liberally amongst friends, but curse words (taboo words) do exist, and some people are bothered by them. It's not an expensive courtesy to just not swear to strangers, so why not extend that courtesy? I'm a big believer in the right to offend, but that doesn't mean we should do so needlessly.
- mikeash 9y agoI agree about "needlessly," but in this case they're providing sub-par information because they don't want to write the word. If the actual name is Big Fucking Rocket, maybe that's what media should report.
- kyberias 9y agoYeah, fuck your opinion about the word fuck in particular!
- twentythree 9y agoI'm sorry I can't find a link to the study right now (I'll add a link if I find it), but one of the most fascinating lectures in my college linguistics class was about swear words, and this exact question. The lecturer claimed that hearing or seeing a swear word has a physiological effect on most people, not unlike being slapped in the face. However, when you replace the text with asterisks or beep it out, the effect is diminished, even if the audience knows exactly what's being replaced. In that context, it makes sense to avoid using swear words in more professional settings if you want to avoid giving the audience the associated emotional reaction; it's distracting at best and offensive at worst, and it's easier just to find another way to communicate which word was meant.
- wwweston 9y ago> It's a fucking word. There's a lot of words that require some sort of care in their use lest some of the potential connotations carried offend or don't communicate intended meaning. You might not care about this word -- or, more likely, you care very much about its use, otherwise you wouldn't be fucking talking about it like fucking pedant who is so fucking proud of his fucking adolescent pretensions of having thought about language -- but you probably care about some words and how their varied and overloaded use can affect communication. (There's a much more diplomatic way I could have my little apositive screed up in the last paragraph. That's part of the point.)
- canjobear 9y agoTaboo words serve a function. They let you communicate something in a way would be costly if overheard in public, thus you can use them as expensive signals, so they make great emotional intensifiers: you only use them if you really mean it. If we were freer with these words, they would be less taboo, thus less costly, and thus less useful. Eventually a new set of taboo words would arise.