It wasn't offensive and I wasn't offended. Sometimes it's a better use of my time to stop reading an article half-way. Anyhow, this post is in the same vein as

It wasn't offensive and I wasn't offended. Sometimes it's a better use of my time to stop reading an article half-way. Anyhow, this post is in the same vein as the AA redesign by Dustin Curtis. The criticism is interesting and useful. The complete redesign attempts are however a step too far. IMHO. You can't suggest solutions to identified flaws by completing changing the parameters of the problem. (I'm not specifically talking about OP here, it's more about redesign posts in general.)