6 ms·
The whole ICO gold rush really looks like a crazy bubble. Accepting for the moment that crypto currencies can have a viable place in the finance system, how man
by simonh 9y ago
The whole ICO gold rush really looks like a crazy bubble. Accepting for the moment that crypto currencies can have a viable place in the finance system, how many of these do we need? What differential value do these new crypto coins offer that Bitcoin, Dogecoin, Etherium or the other existing coins don’t already provide? Honest question, the articles I can find on this don’t really answer this.
- slyfocks 9y agoIn some cases, they actually contribute a novel feature (e.g. Monero adding features that enhance privacy). In most cases (all but a handful), they add nothing. It’s a money grab—so much so, that a somewhat self-aware crypto enthusiast created a parody coin, Useless Ethereum Token, whose sole feature was that it had none. It raised $40k in 3 days and was, at its peak, worth $160k, which is a pretty lofty valuation for a joke.
- corford 9y agoSee also the Fuck Token (http://www.fucktoken.io http://www.fucktoken.io), which raised over $30K in 30 minutes :)
- bhaak 9y agoHey, FUCK at least has a real use case. Making it possible to give a fuck or give no fuck digitally. That's what the world has waited for! /shill mode off
- Semaphor 9y agoI tend to say I can't give a FUCK because I don't have any FUCK left to give. So just by existing they already enriched my life, a truly glorious token.
- padobson 9y agoThis is surely the funniest thing I'm going to see today. I'm going back to bed.
- woah 9y agoThat's not quite true. A lot of these ICOs at least claim to be trying to add some kind of unique features. A lot of them are "utility tokens" which are supposed to be used to pay for the services of a decentralized network. I agree that most of them are garbage, but this isn't like the crapcoins of a few years ago when they were literally just forks of bitcoin with tweaked constants.
- 1ba9115454 9y agoMost of the new offerings are tokens. A whitepaper will list the benefits to the user, usually a % of profits of some new product that the team will bring to the market. So they are acting as company shares. I'm not trying to justify this and I don't buy them myself, but I am watching teams raise serious amounts of cash. To me this seems an easier way to raise cash than going to a bunch of VC's becuase with the ICO craze the due diligince is negligable.
- empath75 9y agoDefrauding people is definitely easier than building a legitimate business.
- vasilipupkin 9y agohow do you defraud people by doing an ICO? if you raise the cash and don't attempt to build a business, you will be caught for fraud and go to jail. It doesn't seem like a great vehicle for fraud
- empath75 9y agoLots of people do it.
- vasilipupkin 9y agodo what? I mean it's one thing to defraud someone and disappear, but in the case of ICO, you put your name out there - there is no escape.
- vkou 9y agoYou then pay yourself salary for the next three years, as well as a generous contract to your uncle Bob's consulting firm, which is supposed to build the product. Sometime in 2020, you post about your incredible journey on your blog, say that all the money has been spent, and the project failed. Whoops, sorry guys. At least, that's a legal way to take ICO money and run. It's not even fraud if you put some effort into delivering on what you promise.
- corford 9y agoAs 1ba9115454 says, most of these ICOs are for tokens. Like the dotcom bubble of 1999/2000, the majority are garbage or pie in the sky but some are interesting and backed by decent teams. A few that are at least plausible (in no particular order and with no implied comment by me on their chances of success/utility): https://funfair.io https://funfair.io https://omg.omise.co https://omg.omise.co https://cosmos.network https://cosmos.network https://0xproject.com https://0xproject.com
- dreit1 9y agoSans ethereum what do you think the market cap of all ico’d tokens is? It’s absolutely tiny. Maybe 5-10 billion? This bubble is overstated to extremes imo
- empath75 9y agoLol 5 billion tiny.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- padobson 9y agoThis seems like a market reaction to increased SEC regulation that has led a lot of companies to delay their IPO. As others have said, there are pink sheet OTC stocks and then there are companies like Snap and Square that only IPO so private equity can make a profit. For average joe investors looking to find opportunities like in the late 90's tech bubble, ICO's seem to be the answer.