I've thought about that quite a lot lately. Here is the strongest explanation of why things are like that and why it's gonna be very difficult to change. For a

I've thought about that quite a lot lately. Here is the strongest explanation of why things are like that and why it's gonna be very difficult to change. For at least a million year, you would have improved your chances of survival by sticking with a physically stronger mate than you are. This guy can beat the wolf when you cant, and maybe more importantly here, he may be able to beat the other tribal chiefs when you cant. Guess how bad people stick to this habit even today. They literally have a brain forged to command them to do that. In practice what happen is that people will confirmation-biased you, they either gonna find out everything you do well, or everything you do badly depending on how badass you are. They will fill forms and say: "look, here are the reasons why we promoted him". From what I've seen, even at Amazon which is a big geniuses recruiter - and therefore should be able to crack this problem - (amazon also have a form "reasons not to promote" which, if you're following, is kinda smart but mostly wishful thinking), people get promoted mostly based on the following leadership principle: the guy who's most likely to beat the wolf is gonna be promoted. I've experienced it first hand. There is a light in the tunnel though. From my observations, I can tell that Amazon, for example, is able to recruit based on skills. Note that at this point, the social bonds aren't made yet which is why it works. This might also explains why you go up the ladder more easily by getting recruited - aka move diagonally. So the best thoughts I've been able to come up with is that, somehow, promotion should try to be like recruitment. Both intuitively and counter-intuitively, I think people should get promoted by people who don't know them, by some sort of recruitment process because we know we can fix that one. In any ways, I guess there is a fantastic startup to be made here.