6 ms·
Equifax CEO Richard Smith Who Oversaw Breach to Collect $90M
- vfulco 9y agoThe risk is all borne on the little people. If strategic direction is an abject failure, C-suite leaves with golden parachutes and the workforce is "rationalized" which means 3rd party consultants are used as justification for draconian cuts. The American Dream these days is to get to the protection (and unjust/unfair risk-free status) of the C-suite umbrella asap.
- abakker 9y agoOne wonders what 90m in security spending would have accomplished...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- manquer 9y agoIn a company like Equifax ? Not much. The issues are/were so systemic without complete change of culture and engineering processes not a lot of improvement in security can be achieved. This is very expensive change management and needs lot of will to push through . Companies of this size generally do not have the appetite for any type of change unless there is clear and present immediate danger that everyone perceives as one. Sadly it takes a breach like this , one that impacts business significantly for most management to move in the right direction as they do not understands the risks fully until then. Just as home/medical insurance is really appreciated by someone who had to pay out of pocket.
- spiketechman 9y agoAbout $53 million short if you ask me..
- Top19 9y agoA big problem with modern capitalism is that there is hardly any risk anymore. Risk is like a rocket ship that has left Earth, gone out of the solar system, and is not present on or near the planet anymore. Your stock can drop 20% in a week, you can oversee the largest theft of valuable information ever recorded in history, and really the only thing that can happen to you is you make just as much money, perhaps more, if none of those things happened. Can’t wait until the “Steve Bannon” of the corporate justice movement emerges to go after these individuals / the structure that creates them.
- Clubber 9y agoThere is risk, it's just transferred. We saw a lot of transferred risk around 2008.
- dogruck 9y agoHow do you define "modern capitalism?"
- FatherCadan 9y agoAnything pre-dating the fractional reserve system. Allowing entities to create value from no effort is not raising capital. Fractional Reserve systems lessen the skin-in-the-game spoken of earlier and transfer to societal decision making from the people doing the work and taking the risk to bureaucracies that are 'too big to fail'.
- dogruck 9y agoInteresting. Now I'm gunna go read up on those concepts. TIL.
- badosu 9y ago> Can’t wait until the “Steve Bannon” of the corporate justice movement emerges to go after these individuals / the structure that creates them. I'm sorry to sidetrack on this, but I was really puzzled by this sentence, that does it mean?
- Top19 9y agoSteve Bannon is kind of known for having a “hit list” within the political establishment. So first it was the Bush’s/Clinton’s, then it was the Koch Brothers, and now he is saying “the day of reckoning” is coming for Karl Rove and Mitch McConnell. Sometimes I think Steve Bannon is crazy, but other times I read his remarks and am shocked by how liberal some of them seem, e.g. his recent comment that Republican plan of tax cuts to the rich is “an economic hate crime” against the working class.
- thegayngler 9y agoHe shouldn't get anything. He costed Equifax lots of money. His handling is going to have Equifax hundreds of millions of dollars going forward.
- partycoder 9y agoA rigged game where if you lose, you win.
- dogruck 9y agoFor all the people who scream at this as unjust -- what do you propose instead? I know your knee-jerk is "pay him $0!" But seriously. If you were on their board. You disregard his employment contract? You don't honor contracts? You make a huge scene and have the CEO exit furiously? And, you do realize the CEO didn't actively facilitate the breech? I'm not defending him, but what would you really suggest?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Canada 9y agoI propose the CEOs payment is put on hold, behind all other creditors. Until all lawsuits are settled and all the creditors arising from them are paid in full he shouldn't see a dime of that money. In several years time, if anything remains of the company, he can collect.
- semperdark 9y agoPeople aren't mad that his contract is being honored, they're annoyed that there are no provisions for gross failure. As for actively facilitating the breach, almost no CEO ever does. One of his jobs is to solve problems indirectly before they show up by appointing the right people to react to them. Appointing his college buddy as the chief of InfoSec was a gross failure to do that.
- dogruck 9y agoTotally fair response. Do you think the board failed to minimize the total financial impact, and that shareholders will now vote to replace most of the board seats? Shareholders run the company. Are we mad at the CEO, or mad at the shareholders?
- semperdark 9y agoIt's hard to say what will happen, but the shareholders would be justified in replacing board members over this. Shareholders don't run public companies directly, I think the farthest that you can logically assign blame is with the board. Did the board fail to minimize total financial impact? In this case, yes. At the same time, adding a "failure" provision to the contract may have scared off good CEOs. I find it unlikely that this CEO has created more value than an overall worse CEO who would have avoided this, but it depends on the outcome of the lawsuits and PR fallout.
- ajobaccount2017 9y agoWhen corporations behave in evil ways (e.g. exploit users, sue independent engineers extending their products, etc.) there is often a mention of shareholder interests making them do this. Where exactly are shareholder interests in this story?
- caseysoftware 9y ago> "After all, the main benefit of Smith retiring from Equifax, as opposed to being fired for cause—besides preserving his dignity—is that he'll get to continue earning his unvested stock compensation, including options and performance-based awards, as though he were still working at the company, according to Equifax policy. That perk, however, could still be revoked." Generally when you leave a company your vesting stops. This is such a sweet deal, it's disgusting. They should have fired him for gross negligence and sue the lot of them. (I know, they're probably thoroughly protected by corp vs individual status, layers of bureaucracy, etc, etc but it makes me feel good saying "sue the bastards!" so let me. ;) )
- nindalf 9y agoI think the issue here is that Equifax's systems are in a bad way. They need a new CEO but if they left the current one in the cold, they'd have a hard time finding a new CEO who'd be willing to bear ultimate responsibility for a system they had 0 influence in building. I believe that's the deal with golden parachutes - in the eyes of corporations, there are very few qualified CEO candidates and these candidates dictate terms - the first of which is a golden parachute.
- FatherCadan 9y agoI heard a commentator (I think from Forbes) say that it is bad that the CEO is leaving because you now have an additional crisis of finding a new one on top of the current mess. Although I suppose this assumes that the now retired CEO has knowledge of the company that is valuable... Time will tell.
- dingo_bat 9y agoSo as a CEO, what is his motivation to ensure the security of his custommer's data? This seems like a motivation to get hacked!
- tim333 9y agoI guess that's just how it works in present day capitalism though there might be a gap for some new laws and court system that could assess damage to the public and fine the directors something based on a guess of their responsibility even if you can't really prove who's fault things were. I doubt the odd injustice of someone not quite guilty losing a chunk of their assets would worry people that much. Like in this case you could fine the ceo say $90m even if he only has part responsibility for the breach.