3 ms·
Yes. I'm well aware of the definitions of a corporation, and totalitarianism, and dystopia. But a priest who appears to have spent the early 20th century potter
by krapp 9y ago
Yes. I'm well aware of the definitions of a corporation, and totalitarianism, and dystopia. But a priest who appears to have spent the early 20th century pottering around the English countryside writing stories about trains was not informed by having lived in a corporate-totalitarian dystopia. So your earlier assertion that this is what Thomas the Tank Engine represents seems specious.
It's a modern reinterpretation of a tv show whose cultural dissonance makes it seem dystopian and authoritarian, but I'm sure someone could find a way to make the Neighborhood of Make-Believe from Mister Rogers seem like a dystopia if they tried. Doesn't mean that's what Fred Rogers was going for.
- colordrops 9y agoUnless he was a hermit living in a cave, he was well immersed in society. And in fact his stories are about one of the main symbols of modern corporate industrial society: The train.
- krapp 9y ago>And in fact his stories are about one of the main symbols of modern corporate industrial society: The train. He liked trains. He made up stories about them as a child, imagining them as characters talking to each other, then wrote those stories down for his own son years later. He didn't consider trains to be a symbol of corporate oppression or dystopia.
- colordrops 9y agoYou keep putting meaning to my words where there was none. I did not say that he considered trains to be a symbol of corporate oppression or dystopia. In fact the entire point of my original comment is that you can be completely unaware of any idea of a corporate dystopia and still write a story that includes symbols of corporate dystopia because you are just using the things you see around you day to day in your stories.
- krapp 9y agoOk. I must be misinterpreting your comments, then, because I read "Almost all the content we've got is representative of 'corporate-totalitarian dystopia', because we live in a corporate-totalitarian dystopia" as implying that all media (including Thomas the Tank Engine) is an allegory by the authors of the 'corporate-totalitarian dystopia' in which they live. If your point is that content is interpreted by people who believe they live in a dystopia as being representative of it, then I suppose I would agree. I've seen people read dystopian symbolism into the Teletubbies, too, although that, like many such subversions, seems to be an attempt at contrarian humor. If that interpretation can be so broadly applied, then it's most likely lacking in depth. In this case, since the author had no intention for his stories to represent "corporate-totalitarian dystopia" then what does it signify to say that they do? It seems like a tautological statement.
- colordrops 9y agoHeh that's my original point. There is nothing particularly wrong with Thomas. Glad we can come to an agreement.
- jessaustin 9y agoPriests are the public face of the most totalitarian dystopian corporation ever to menace humanity. I guess if we're talking about an English priest he probably worked for a different such corporation that split off from the original about 500 years ago... They didn't split in order to cut back on the dystopian totalitarianism!
- krapp 9y agoOk, you're just shitposting.