3 ms·
Yes, we did live in a corporate-totalitarian dystopia in the 40s to 70s. And you are being lazy for assuming things that I did not say. I'm not implying that
by colordrops 9y ago
Yes, we did live in a corporate-totalitarian dystopia in the 40s to 70s.
And you are being lazy for assuming things that I did not say. I'm not implying that it's propaganda. I'm saying that media reflects the world we live in, as that is the context that we are familiar with, and we tell stories set in our own world.
- krapp 9y ago> Yes, we did live in a corporate-totalitarian dystopia in the 40s to 70s. I understand people like to interpret things through that lens now but like seeing Tolkien's work as an allegory for industrialization or the atomic bombs, it seems to me to be mostly post-hoc revisionism to do so. Reading the Wikipedia page of the author, I don't see any evidence of a "corporate-totalitarian dystopia" which would inform his stories. So you're going to have to define "corporate-totalitarian dystopia" in a way that even makes sense in that context.
- colordrops 9y agoSo just to be clear I'm mostly talking about the US and western countries. Let's break it down: Corporate: the corporation has been the main organizational unit for most of society at least since the 40s. In fact the vast majority of Americans that have a vocation work under a corporation. Totalitarian: The definition of totalitarianism is "a system of government that is centralized and dictatorial and requires complete subservience to the state." Despite noises to the contrary, the US is certainly not a democracy, and I wouldn't even call it a representative republic. A data-driven study [1] confirms the intuitions of many that the US is really an oligarchy of the wealthy corporate class. US politics is driven by corporate interests and there is little evidence that public sentiment has a large effect on material outcomes, despite external appearances. Furthermore it can be argued that the US is a police state, as described by Pulitzer prize winning journalist Chris Hedges [2]. The US government has had countless programs to control discourse and put down opposition since its inception, and anything that threatens the status quo is stomped out with prejudice. Dystopia: In many important factors, American citizens are unhappy with their lives, and this unhappiness can be traced back to the corporate-totalitarian nature of the US. Extremely expensive health care, long work hours without much vacation, economic disparity between classes, lack of affordable housing, complete corruption of the financial sector, regulatory capture, endless warfare, corporate control of the media, etc are all direct results of the structure of our society. [1] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-politics/article/testing-theories-of-american-politics-elites-interest-groups-and-average-citizens/62327F513959D0A304D4893B382B992B# https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-poli... [2] https://www.truthdig.com/articles/the-origins-of-our-police-state/ https://www.truthdig.com/articles/the-origins-of-our-police-...
- krapp 9y agoYes. I'm well aware of the definitions of a corporation, and totalitarianism, and dystopia. But a priest who appears to have spent the early 20th century pottering around the English countryside writing stories about trains was not informed by having lived in a corporate-totalitarian dystopia. So your earlier assertion that this is what Thomas the Tank Engine represents seems specious. It's a modern reinterpretation of a tv show whose cultural dissonance makes it seem dystopian and authoritarian, but I'm sure someone could find a way to make the Neighborhood of Make-Believe from Mister Rogers seem like a dystopia if they tried. Doesn't mean that's what Fred Rogers was going for.
- colordrops 9y agoUnless he was a hermit living in a cave, he was well immersed in society. And in fact his stories are about one of the main symbols of modern corporate industrial society: The train.
- krapp 9y ago>And in fact his stories are about one of the main symbols of modern corporate industrial society: The train. He liked trains. He made up stories about them as a child, imagining them as characters talking to each other, then wrote those stories down for his own son years later. He didn't consider trains to be a symbol of corporate oppression or dystopia.
- colordrops 9y agoYou keep putting meaning to my words where there was none. I did not say that he considered trains to be a symbol of corporate oppression or dystopia. In fact the entire point of my original comment is that you can be completely unaware of any idea of a corporate dystopia and still write a story that includes symbols of corporate dystopia because you are just using the things you see around you day to day in your stories.
- 9y ago