3 ms·
I am rather disappointed that the mortgage rebates will remain in effect in this cut, providing an additional advantage to those who purchase and build up asset
by munk-a 9y ago
I am rather disappointed that the mortgage rebates will remain in effect in this cut, providing an additional advantage to those who purchase and build up assets rather than rent is unnecessary.
It also looks like this cut would make it even more advantageous to use an S-corp for funneling income from contract work. Piggy-backing onto methods used to reduce top-earner's tax burden always has it's advantages for those who can exploit it, I guess.
- djrogers 9y agoYou realize that the tax deduction for mortgages lowers the cost of rent by reducing the expenses involved in maintaining a large capital investment like a rental house?
- munk-a 9y agoIt does, but not at an even amount. The tax deductions lower the cost of operating a unit for renting, but that doesn't mean all the money saved gets translated directly to benefiting the renters.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> You realize that the tax deduction for mortgages lowers the cost of rent by reducing the expenses involved in maintaining a large capital investment like a rental house In a sense the does, but that's somewhat illusory. As with other businesses, any reasonable and necessary expenses of maintaining and managing the property being rented are deductible as business expenses for landlords; mortgage interest is, AFAIK, currently excluded from that only because, with the mortgage interest deduction, it would be double counted. Virtually no one who supports removing the mortgage interest deduction opposes the general notion of deduction of reasonable and necessary business expenses.
- s73ver_ 9y agoIf you got rid of mortgage interest, then almost no one could afford to buy a home.
- munk-a 9y agoI think that the government should guarantee housing for everyone, but the mortgage interest rebate doesn't do that. It does allow some portion of the population that couldn't afford a home be able to do so, but that doesn't hold for anyone. Why don't we instead funnel those funds into HUD and provide housing as a right either through urban development projects or through subsidizing privatized low income housing construction (possibly by eating a tax reduction via incentives)? FYI, I'm an expatriate living in BC, Canada where housing prices are insane and almost nobody can afford to buy a home, but the economic reasons here are more specialized to the region.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIf you got rid of the mortgage interest deduction, the market clearing price of homes would fall. (Add an income-based tax subsidy on principal payments on homes—either up front or as part of loan repayment—and you'll do a lot more to improve affordability without doing as much to encourage debt.)
- s73ver_ 9y agoI'm not so sure about the first sentence. And I'd be all for the second, but I'm even more sure that simply won't happen in this political climate.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoIt indirectly does do something about the mortgage interest deduction by increasing the standard deduction to $24,000 for married couples. Renters who don't itemize will benefit, and will be on an even playing field with many homeowners who won't be able to beat the $24,000 standard deduction by itemizing, even with mortgage interest. It would be better to get rid of the mortgage interest deduction entirely, but it is politically impossible at this point.