3 ms·
Why don't they just automatically call lawyers for young people? That would be a better way to protect the rights of young people.
by DanBC 9y ago
Why don't they just automatically call lawyers for young people? That would be a better way to protect the rights of young people.
- emeraldd 9y agoHaving the right to an attorney does not mean that you are required to have an attorney. On top of that, if the persons family already has an attorney then I'd imagine there are all kinds of issues with adding a court appointed one to the mix.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikestew 9y agoFine, then just make it a requirement that some kind of attorney be present before interrogating an underage suspect. I mean, hell, you can't sell them cigarettes or liquor, you can't have sex with them, we don't let them drive before they're almost an adult. Yet when the cops show up we'll let them flap their gums without professional advice when it's almost certainly against their best interests to do so. When I was sixteen, I can guarantee that I was better equipped to decide whether or not to smoke than I was in deciding whether or not to talk to cops. One decision requires a bit of common sense, the other is best suited to those with six years of schooling.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 9y agobut if the desire is to protect the rights of vulnerable people, and to make convictions more reliable, it's easier to just make sure anyone under 18 or with a borderline learning disability gets an Appropriate Adult. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appropriate_adult https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appropriate_adult
- wtallis 9y agoFrom the article: > Last spring the county adopted a new ordinance that requires juveniles detained at the Juvenile Detention Center in Seattle to get advice from an attorney before talking to law enforcement.
- mulmen 9y agoBut that's not until they are detained which is already way too late to prevent lasting harm.