3 ms·
I enjoy (as humor) the articles where this is discussed as a plot by New Zealand to be declared a continent. I imagine if there were people from Pluto living am
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I enjoy (as humor) the articles where this is discussed as a plot by New Zealand to be declared a continent. I imagine if there were people from Pluto living among us they would be telling us how planet like Pluto is :-)
But humor aside, where do you draw the line? Nearly all of the Mojave desert in the US was clearly a sea floor based on the fossils found in its sandstone rocks. But we're not going to call it an ocean. It was an ocean, and then things moved around and now it is a desert. Zealandia was a continent but now its the seafloor around an island.
Lets say we call it a continent, does it suddenly make it all the territory of the government of New Zealand? Does that mean they control fishing and mineral rights for hundreds of kilometers beyond the shores of their island? Where does that lead?
- seszett 9y ago> Lets say we call it a continent, does it suddenly make it all the territory of the government of New Zealand? Does that mean they control fishing and mineral rights for hundreds of kilometers beyond the shores of their island? Probably, yes. France extended its EEZ last year with new evidence that the land around Kerguelen island forms an underwater "continent" as well. I imagine if this finding about Zealandia gets confirmed, both New Zealand and France (from New Caledonia) will want to extend their EEZ there as well.
- rgbrenner 9y agoMore on france's extension of it's eez: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=536dc880-b89b-4fbe-bff1-72dc1c46e2c8 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=536dc880-b89b... Note, the extension is from 200mi (the eez) up to 350mi -- so NZ wouldn't get the entire continental area.. and in that extended area, they only get exclusive rights to the soil and subsoil (so things like oil, etc... but no exclusive fishing rights).
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAnd this is, I expect, all the motivation they need. I'm sure Australia will be irritated.
- continental 9y agoI was under the impression continents were roughly defined by the underlying continental plates.
- Taniwha 9y agoyes I think that's exactly the point here, despite most of the surface being underwater the big deal is that there's a continental plate down there
- craftyguy 9y agoIf you go far enough back, South America and Africa were 1 continent. Go even further and, at several times, there was only 1 continent on Earth. Go even further back and there were no continents. So maybe we should just to away with the notion of having continents in the first place.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThat would be the ad absurdium argument :-). But the EEZ[1] argument is the one that is in play here. Generally the 'oceans' are international water, and what is under them is not claimed by any country. There are economic and strategic assets here, whether it is oil or methane clathrates, fisheries, or places to establish forward operating bases, these things are 'easy' to claim in your 'own' territory and 'hard' to claim in international waters. Step 1, redefine them to not be international waters. See the South China Sea and now Zealandia ... [1] Extended Economic Zone
- craftyguy 9y agoAd absurdium arguments are my favorite :) Totally understand the implications of EEZ, but at some point you have to draw the line else the line will become increasingly more arbitrary as countries try to fuzz the boundaries of what a continent is and is not. Why does any country get to lay claim on a chunk of seafloor that has been uninhabitable for land animals far longer than humans have been around as a species?
- rgbrenner 9y agoWhy does any country get to lay claim on a chunk of seafloor that has been uninhabitable for land animals far longer than humans have been around as a species? United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Convention_on_the_Law_of_the_Sea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Convention_on_t... It's true this is unfair to marine animals, but that's really their fault for not attending the meetings when the treaty was signed.
- Taniwha 9y agoAs a kiwi I don't think we actually have this as an idea, but thanks for the suggestion