5 ms·
Too bad that the Purism Libre5 won’t qualify for FSF’s RYF¹ certification². I’m sorry, I really don’t mean to come off as snarkily dismissive as this might app
by teddyh 9y ago
Too bad that the Purism Libre5 won’t qualify for FSF’s RYF¹ certification². I’m sorry, I really don’t mean to come off as snarkily dismissive as this might appear. Let me try again.
This project certainly seems to try to do their very best, and what they have achieved might be all that’s possible to achieve at the present time. I just wanted to, as politely as I might, note that there are those of us for this is a dealbreaker, and that we will rather go without than get the current good-enough product. (If there were none of us, there would be no commercial incentive for any company to keep improving in the right direction.)
I really don’t mean to dismiss anyone’s effort; honestly.
1. https://www.fsf.org/ryf https://www.fsf.org/ryf
2. https://puri.sm/shop/librem-5/ https://puri.sm/shop/librem-5/
- Arathorn 9y agowhich bit disqualifies for RYF ooi? the need for a proprietary baseband module, even if it’s “external”?
- teddyh 9y agoThat information is in the second link I provided.
- Arathorn 9y agoOh, sorry - missed it in the FAQ. My understanding (which isn’t particularly well researched) is that any 3G or 4G packet data requires implementing algorithms (compression and error corection stuff) which are unfortunately encumbered with software patents, and cannot be implemented in a FOSS manner unless someone paid the licensing fees for everyone (similar to Cisco paying the H.264 patent fees for OpenH264), or the patent pool gets bored and relinquishes their patents.
- craftyguy 9y agoWhen do the patents expire?
- Arathorn 9y agoUnsure - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LTE_(telecommunication)#Patents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LTE_(telecommunication)#Patent... is pretty depressing, if 3-5% of handset manufacturer revenue goes on paying off the patents :( Separate to patents, I suspect there are also 'secret' constants (lookup tables for compression codes etc) which folks may attempt to copyright, a bit like the DVD CSS secrets...
- Etzos 9y agoConsidering how they phrased it and the fact that no phone has the FSF's RYF certification I would tend to think it's because it's currently impossible. That they took the time to add a note about RYF certification and that they will continue to keep the FSF up to date on this shows that they do care about this. I honestly don't think there's any more you could ask of them.
- teddyh 9y ago> it's currently impossible. […] I honestly don't think there's any more you could ask of them. I don’t dispute that. I have no ill will towards them. I just, you know, won’t actually be buying the phone until one exists which is RYF-certified. I just felt it important that someone pointed this out – while surely their effort towards RYF compliance counts for much, it won’t get me all the way towards actually buying it. I’ll wish them all the luck in actually achieving it, but I (at least) won’t be buying anything until they actually get there.
- Etzos 9y agoI suppose I can understand this reasoning a bit, but it seems a little counter intuitive to me. There is literally no alternative. And without efforts like this it's unlikely there would ever be something that is RYF compliant. Accomplishing something like RYF certification requires work, money, and someone willing to try to accomplish it. There is someone that is willing to invest work to at least attempt to accomplish it, but they need money. Why not support them in their quest for this?
- teddyh 9y agoSuppose that I’m a vegetarian, but I really like sausage (maybe I acquired the taste before becoming vegetarian), but there are, for some reason, no makers of vegetarian sausages. Should I then accept whatever sausage is available which has the least amount of meat in it? Of course not; I’ll simply go without sausage. Even if a sausage maker came along and tried to attract the vegetarian buyers with a new kind of sausage which had no meat in it, just a little bit of gelatin in it. They say they can’t currently make vegetarian sausage without any gelatin in it, but they’re working on it. Should I “support” them and buy the sausage with gelatin in it anyway? Of course not; I’m a vegetarian; gelatin means it’s off the table. (I’m not necessarily really a vegetarian, of course; it’s just an analogy.)
- mixedbit 9y agoIf they manage to launch Libre 5, the future iterations may fix this shortcoming. If Libre 5 fails, we are stuck with Android & iPhone, which have much bigger problems.
- mlinksva 9y agoEven if Librem 5 fails, there will be subsequent fund-a-significantly-more-free-phone attempts. $1.5m is really a small amount. Anyway I do hope Librem 5 succeeds (meeting threshold, shipping...going mass market...) and will probably back it.
- craftyguy 9y ago> we will rather go without than get the current good-enough product What are you using now? > If there were none of us, there would be no commercial incentive for any company to keep improving in the right direction Well, no, the current Librem5 campaign shows there are folks who are willing to shell out money for something drastically better than any other solutions out there today. It's not perfect, but I would rather encourage companies who are striving towards perfection even if they are not perfect today. I think Purism understands that there are still gaps in coverage, they even admit it on the campaign page. If they no longer make progress towards closing those gaps in future products, then I'm right there with you.. they should be dropped. My philosophy aligns more with the FSFE than the FSF.