21 ms·
> Often times there are hard barriers preventing people from starting a company. In these cases my best advice is to move to a tech hub (preferably the Bay Area
by ryandrake 9y ago
> Often times there are hard barriers preventing people from starting a company. In these cases my best advice is to move to a tech hub (preferably the Bay Area) and work for a tech company until you can save the money
I had to laugh there. Moving to the Bay Area will reduce your ability to save money, not increase it. I was probably saving 40-50% of my salary when I worked in Nowhereville, Florida. With the housing costs out here in the Bay Area, the long commute (wear and tear on vehicles) and the massive local and state taxes, it's almost impossible to save.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hellbreaker 9y agoI keep on hearing about that.. so what's savings rate people should expect in SF?
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoDepends on your salary and general lifestyle. Single with no kids helps. Commuting from the East Bay helps. Not eating out or having expensive hobbies helps. Not owning a car helps. Making more than the typical low-to-mid 6 figures helps. Not having an onerous student loan burden or consumer debt helps. I've personally been saving over $2k/mo on an after-tax income of just over $6k/mo, haven't been trying particularly hard to max that out though.
- cellis 9y agoIf you're single without kids -- 50% easily. Perhaps someone with kids can comment.
- liveoneggs 9y agoyou're lucky to max out your 401k
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoPeople with children in SF either have locked in cheap housing due to Prop 13, make top-2% salary, or move out. Like, seriously, SF proper has half the primary-school-aged children than it should. It's not just people not having kids - SF has approximately the "right" number of infants and preschoolers. Under-appreciated fact about SF: your kid's schooling choices are either winning the school assignment lottery, having a 50 minute commute, homeschooling, or moving to a city that actually handles things sanely and has lower housing costs to boot.
- danans 9y agoIf you and your partner both work full time, factor 20k+/kid/year for child care. If you later send your children to private schools, factor roughly the same rate. If instead you choose to send your kids to a public school that provides good educational opportunities, factor in either several thousand in additional local property taxes [1] or similar amounts in donations to the school PTA [2]. [1] http://www.paloaltopulse.com/2014/10/16/palo-alto-pulse-asks-how-does-school-funding-work-in-palo-alto/ http://www.paloaltopulse.com/2014/10/16/palo-alto-pulse-asks... [2] http://capta.org/pta-leaders/run-your-pta/finance/fundraising/ http://capta.org/pta-leaders/run-your-pta/finance/fundraisin...
- jakelarkin 9y agobeen running this math recently: quality child care or private school is +$2k/month/child +2bdrm housing $4k food/transport/other $2k for couple with one kid you're at $8k/month post-tax or $150k/year pre-tax to break even.
- tezzer 9y agoSubsidized day care is $1900/mo for 2 kids; rent on a 3 bedroom house with a serious termite problem and an absentee landlord who doesn't care is $3300, babysitters are $20/hr if you want to go see a movie. Couples with 2 full time tech workers are fine (although they tend to not think so). I've got a spouse who works part time outside of tech and we make it work. We'll never buy a house here, and we had a landlord raise rent $1000 (33%) overnight once so you never really rest easy, but if you love your job it's a good place to be.
- mmm94720 9y agoLet me describe a typical mid-career Silicon Valley salaried tech worker scenario. YMMV of course. Base comp 200K Bonus, stock, 401k match 50K Total gross comp 250K Expenses: Taxes 40% (30% fed, 10% state) 100K Rental housing 40K ($3300/month) Food 15K Transportation 15K Discretionary spending 20K Total expenses 190K As a result, you can comfortably save $60K per year. Of course, kids and housing options will add greatly to your spend.
- ryandrake 9y agoHere we go again with the "typical" tech worker making 250K. According to Glassdoor [1] and Payscale [2] the median/average base pay for SW engineers in the SF is about 1/2 of that. 1: https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/san-francisco-software-engineer-salary-SRCH_IL.0,13_IM759_KO14,31.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/san-francisco-software-en... 2: https://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Senior_Software_Engineer/Salary/11028638/San-Francisco-CA https://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Senior_Software_Eng...
- akhilcacharya 9y agoThat sounds more like a new grad salary...
- Bahamut 9y agoGlassdoor skews low due to having more historical data. It should be noted that a lot of people also work in the Valley & live in SF since companies there pay more in general (although rent in the Valley has been rising the past few years in general, especially in Palo Alto and Mountain View). Of course it's a terrible commute, but some people prefer that - it should also be noted that the comment you responded to was talking about the Valley, not SF. Software engineering jobs in SF proper is a raw deal IMO excepting that you get to live in SF & be closer to the offerings of SF (or you can commute into SF, but might as well be commuting to an area with better pay IMO). Engineering quality is probably roughly the same across the Bay Area though.
- stale2002 9y agoYou are half right, and half wrong. The average startups are not paying engineers anywhere close to 250k. But I can assure you that every one of the big 5 tech companies pays those numbers (as do the "hot" unicorns that are on a similar "tier" as Google, ect) . The moral of the story is, don't work for a startup. Go big or go home. Sell out and work for one of the companies with the actual money. Because at those companies, those numbers are real. And the thing that people need to realize is that those "top" companies have a whole lot of people working for them. The numbers don't back up the common argument that is made about how "you have to be in the very top 1 percent of engineers to work at Google, FB, or Amazon".
- sidlls 9y agoDepends on your circumstances. If you're single, 50% or more, easily. If you're married/living with a partner or roommate, even more. If you have kids and/or significant debt, that drops significantly (my family of four saves about 10%).
- brndnmtthws 9y agoIt really depends on the kind of lifestyle you choose. If you want to live alone in a fancy apartment, drive a new car, and eat out every day, then you certainly won't be able to save as much. If you practice frugality, find cheap housing (which does exist if you look hard enough), and don't spend money on things you don't need, then it's quite easy to save a lot of money.
- autotune 9y ago> fancy apartment Being a 400 sq. ft. studio that you pay $3k per month for to live in an area where you won't get stabbed when you go out at night and is close enough to work where you don't need a car.
- NikolaeVarius 9y agoWhy would you ever live in a studio if you want to save money?
- autotune 9y agoWhy would you ever live with roommates if you want to be sane and productive at work each day?
- introvertsexist 9y agoPresumably for sanity & security & sleep. Fuck you; this attitude to rent is the worst part about the bay area. If you want to save money, please avoid the bay at all costs.
- Woofles 9y agoOr consider that the bay is more than SF. I recently moved to Oakland and I'm paying around $1k/mo on rent compared to $2k/mo or more living in the city while not really giving up any of the benefits of living in the area.
- 9y ago
- encoderer 9y agoI think it depends primarily on if you work for a tech company or a startup.
- ryandrake 9y agoI've worked at start-ups, failing tech companies, moderately successful tech companies and well-known names. I'm convinced that, unless you lucked into the 1 in 1000 unicorn, it doesn't matter what kind of company you work for--the area you live in's cost of living largely dominates the question of how much you can save.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cachemiss 9y agoIf you are bootstrapping, and you are starting a company in an area that does not need the top tier of engineers (which is most of them, regardless of how they talk about hiring the best), I'd consider starting someplace low cost. I think college towns in the midwest / rust belt are untapped resources, or areas that used to have strong technically focused companies that moved away. I've personally seen founders bootstrap and launch successful companies (B2B with real revenue, not Uber for cats) in areas with little tech presence. The ability to not have to shell out huge salaries and equity was a real winner, there's also less distractions. You can get strong engineers (no, not SV / Seattle top end engineers, but people that can throw together a reasonable website) for < 100k in these areas, and they won't bounce around as much. You aren't competing with AmaFaceGoogSoft here, you're competing with HR companies and random consulting houses. There's disadvantages to being outside of the tech bubble, but advantages too. That being said, for an employee, you should at least try and do some time in SV / Seattle etc.
- segmondy 9y agoBut I thought the internet removed all boundaries? Why do we need to be in the Bay area to have access to top tier of engineers? They are also everywhere else and let's say they are in the Bay area, that's what remote is for right?
- cachemiss 9y agoWe aren't going to agree on this, around remote employees. I believe there is value to co-located teams, not everyone agrees and that's fine. The other point is, most startups do not need that talented of engineers, they think they do, but they don't. You don't want to pay bay area salaries if you don't have to, and in most of these areas, you don't have to. If you are somewhere else but the bay, and you are paying people bay area salaries, but you aren't in SV, so you aren't raising VC like SV companies, I don't think that's a winning move.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI think people are still afraid of hiring people for remote work, especially for critical roles such as first few technical people in a company.
- gxs 9y agoThis is an insult to the thousands of people who make it in the bay area on barista wages. Just fucking wow. You can save in the bay area, live with roommates and pay <2k rent. If you can keep yourself from eating at all the trendy restaurants you can spend ~500 on food tops. At a salary of 100k you should be able to save 1500-2k per month comfortably. You don't even have to do that forever, just long enough to move up a bit in your job and save for a downpayment if buying a home is your goal. Not to mention if your spouse works and makes similar money then you can live a really high quality of life. If you think you're entitled to owning a big house, 2 cars, with money left over for dining out everyday and to pad your savings for a 5M retirement fund, you're going to have a bad time.
- bpchaps 9y agoA SF barista makes 18k/yr. Can they make it on that? Sure. But when a third of your salary is on food - based on your quote - it's not going to be comfortable and saving is a stretch to say the least. Especially with student loans and such.
- guiomie 9y ago"A SF barista makes 18k/yr" ... where did you come up with this number? Sounds quite unrealistic...
- bpchaps 9y agoHere's how - https://imgur.com/a/S00fk https://imgur.com/a/S00fk
- mercutio2 9y agoThe minimum wage in SF is currently $14/hour. Quoting a salary rate for part time work doesn’t really make sense. Baristas who work 40 hour weeks will make (minimum) $28k, and SF provides subsidized or free health insurance on top of that. That’s still not enough to live on, but let’s not exaggerate.
- 9y ago
- mahyarm 9y ago80k* %50 = 40k vs. 160k * %35 = 56k Bay area in a nutshell. You can have higher savings rates too, I do around %40 and I could save even more. Working at a startup does make it harder, usually it's better to work at FANG. You also learn a lot and realize the difference between 'facebook does this dev practice because it's huge so it has to vs. it's the better practice'
- nightski 9y agoOr you know, you don't have to be average and can do 300k * 60% consulting or doing some other slightly more ambitious method while still not living in the bay area.
- fny 9y agoBy argument above, you'd still expect to make significantly more in the Bay Area.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kobeya 9y agoOutside of a few very highly specialized fields, I don't know anyone who does that successfully who didn't first get their start and build their network in the valley. EDIT: To be clear, I do know people that have "done their time" then left and pulled in really nice consulting rates working remotely from rural / flyover america or overseas, albeit often with a lot of travel to customer sites.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- BeetleB 9y ago>Bay area in a nutshell. You can have higher savings rates too Your example is a higher savings amount, not rate. In your example, I may still prefer the 80K one. Why? Assume taxes are a third of your salary in both places. In the 80K job, you save 40K, and your living expenses are 13.3K In the 160K job, you save 56K and your living expenses are 50.7K In Nowhereville, you are saving 3 times your annual cost of living. In SV, you are saving just a little more than 1x. The result? Even though you save more in SV, you will not be able to retire quicker. (My claim of 1/3 in taxes in both places is likely inaccurate, but the essence of the calculation doesn't change). A higher saving amount does not mean earlier retirement (unless you move to a cheap city to retire).
- yesimahuman 9y agoYea the adage that you should move to the bay area to start a startup feels increasingly outdated. I couldn't have gone full time on my (now VC-backed startup) back when we were bootstrapping and living on $2k a month from early customer credit card swipes (one of the absolute best feelings in the world) if we had living costs like that in SF/bay area. Once we did find traction and raise we still didn't move. Times are changing. Plus, doesn't pg say the most important thing is to just stay alive?
- pcsanwald 9y agoDid you find it harder to raise VC outside the bay area? We definitely did when we were raising for our Baltimore based company. Whereas now that I live in the bay area, I see companies get funded all the time and think to myself they would never get funded if they were HQ'd elsewhere.
- yesimahuman 9y agoI think it's safe to say that's harder to raise bay area VC if you're not there, though I did do it for our Series A. It's not impossible, and considering "ease of raising VC" isn't the primary variable I optimize for (and doing so seems to be falling out of vogue), I don't think it warrants moving. Some investors just can't get over location, and I think that says more about them than it does you. At this point I also get a little kick out of doing things differently and trying to change the ecosystem. Isn't that what being a contrarian is all about?
- segmondy 9y agoIf you don't mind, what's your location?
- yesimahuman 9y agoOur primary office is in Madison, WI (recently opened another in Boston)
- austenallred 9y agoI don’t think the purpose of moving to the Bay Area in this sentence is to save more money. It’s to get connected and plugged into the scene. For what it’s worth I did exactly that - moved to the SF Bay Area, started saving (you can still do it if you don’t have debt), and those connections and that experience really matter. I don’t think we could have gotten into YC without them.
- sidlls 9y agoOn the other hand I was only saving around 10% of my income in. Nowhereville, Midwest (similar cost of living to Nowhereville, FL). I moved to the Bay Area. I'm still saving about the same rate, but it's a percentage of more than double the income. I doubt 40% of Nowhereville, FL salary is as much as 20% of Bay Area salary for a large number of cases. Developer compensation in Nowhereville caps out much lower than it does in the Bay Area (I'm talking base salary): figure in RSUs and other benefits (e.g. job abundance) and it's almost a no-brainer that a move to the Bay Area is better.
- crazy5sheep 9y agoIt really depends on what kind of apartment you live in. for a luxury one, it can easily burn you 3k+ for a 1b1b, however, if you are ok with sharing space with the landlord and other roommates, for one bedroom, it's usually around 800 including utilities and internet in south bay. And you probably don't need to pay for food or gym, most big companies provide that.
- slewis 9y agoHere's my counter-anecdote. I hesitate to do this but I think it's nice for aspiring software engineers to have details. I moved to San Francisco in 2006 straight out of college to work at Google as a SWE. I was $27k in debt (student loan + credit card). My rent was $1450 at the time (2 bedroom with a roommate in a nice part of town), and I took out a $26k loan to buy a car. I'm not particularly frugal. I did well at Google, left in 2010 with >$200k saved, and used that to fund my entrepreneurial adventures from then til now. I was very fortunate to land that job, YMMV.
- driverdan 9y agoSo 7-11 years ago. Not very relevant anymore since the cost of living has increased significantly in SF since then.
- kobeya 9y agoThose numbers are still reasonable for the South Bay, which has just as much opportunity, or the East Bay where you could commute in to SF. Or for someone more frugal than the GP. I get what you're saying, but it's still possible to work.
- rconti 9y ago7-11 years ago everyone was saying exactly the same thing about the cost of living here as they are now.
- jsmthrowaway 9y ago$1,450/2BR in SF is the giveaway that this is a dated, and no longer even remotely likely, anecdote.
- falsedan 9y ago40% of $45k is 12% of $150k, and that doesn't value in the experience and networking opportunities of working in the Bay Area
- tlogan 9y agoI guess they wanted to say "starting a startup" - not starting a company. To have a successful company (not a VC startup) you really just need to code a little and know to market/sell (or have co-founder who can do that). And you will be fine - not rich but fine. Of course, the above is only true if you live in Bay Area... If you live in Bay Area, then you will need at least $250K/year to live "fine". Which is about $150K/year in Austin, TX.
- frakkingcylons 9y agoSaying it's impossible to save is misleading and it's laughable how often this myth about the Bay Area is perpetuated on HN. Unlike a lot of places in the US, the Bay Area has all of the following: * a meaningful degree of racial diversity (makes a big difference if you're not white) * comprehensive public transit (yeah, yeah BART and MUNI suck, but where I've lived in the US previously, they didn't even exist) * an abundance of job opportunities in tech * nice weather I'm able to save 40% of my income and I don't even work at a high-paying company like Airbnb, Google etc. I live in a new apartment with one roommate in an area that's only a 25 minute commute to my office in SF via public transit.
- jdmichal 9y agoThis comment, in turn, is laughable from a guy in his 30's with a wife and toddler... We live on a single income and have our own house with a quarter acre of land. And this is in coastal Florida, not a economically-depressed city in the Midwest. We all need to accept that people are looking for different things in life. It's difficult to save money in SF, while also having a lifestyle that's relatively easy to maintain in other places. For instance, living without roommates.
- encoderer 9y agoThe commenter could be 10 years your junior. I'm mid 30s, wife, kid on the way, and own a home in Sfba with reasonable commute.
- felipellrocha 9y agoApproaching my 30s, with a wife and no kids yet. We have about 75% of our salaries. It's possible
- frakkingcylons 9y agoYou're right that it's difficult if you have a family. But there's a lot of room in between "impossible to save" and "saving is difficult".
- 9y ago
- itake 9y agocounter anecdote - I moved from Atlanta, GA earning $70k/yr ($4k/mo after taxes) to SF earning ($6.5k/mo after taxes). In Atl, I saved $2k/mo. In SF, I saved $3k/mo. Its hard to save $3k/mo if you're only making $4k/mo. In SF, I took a huge lifestyle hit. No car, no apartment to myself, eating out less. which let me save a lot more.
- rconti 9y agoPeople who can save can save anywhere. People who will overspend will overspend anywhere. This doesn't mean move to the Bay Area to be a janitor. Some jobs will absolutely make it difficult to afford the cost of living. But with good discipline, I'd argue it's typically easier to save (in absolute dollar terms) in a high-COL place than a low one.