3 ms·
an opaque process of decision-making (complete with several non-official-bodies, non-accountable to anyone, that nevertheless convene and take decisions that af
by pavlov 9y ago
an opaque process of decision-making (complete with several non-official-bodies, non-accountable to anyone, that nevertheless convene and take decisions that affect all member states)
Can you specify what you mean by this?
- coldtea 9y agoBodies like the Euro-group, a non-official body that "although it can impose tough conditions for bailing out struggling member countries or rescuing banks, it publishes no official minutes, has no headquarters, and the people who function as its secretariat have other day jobs".
- oblio 9y agoThey're the finance ministers of member countries. For them to be there someone has to vote in the respective governments... Indirect democracy is still democracy. Heck, it's even the form of democracy 90% of democracies out there use.
- ZenoArrow 9y ago> "Indirect democracy is still democracy" How about an oligarchy, is that still a democracy? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligarchy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oligarchy
- oblio 9y agoOf course not, but that's assuming that the shadowy "Eurogroup" decides everything. Which is not true. The European Parliament is democratically elected, the European Council is (indirectly) democratically elected, the European Council is literally the heads of states elected, again, democratically, by member countries. The European Commission is not democratically elected, because guess what, no public administration is fully democratically elected. No state could ever function if its "plumbers" are changed 100% every 4 years. The UK doesn't do it, Switzerland doesn't do it, Australia doesn't do it, France doesn't do it, etc.
- pavlov 9y agoNo state could ever function if its "plumbers" are changed 100% every 4 years. To be fair, the United States tries to do mostly that -- and the utter dysfunction of 2017 has demonstrated the dangers of that approach.
- oblio 9y agoNot even Trump does that. Imagine replacing all librarians or doctors or lawyers or whatever, down to the lowest levels of state administration. And then do that every 4 years. Insanity! :)
- ZenoArrow 9y ago> "No state could ever function if its "plumbers" are changed 100% every 4 years." We're not talking about the "plumbers", we're talking about the "bosses", and I'd suggest to you it's a bit of a stretch to call an institution where corporations have a very strong influence on the selection of bosses as something that is truly democratic. Representative or direct democracy is required to counteract the influence of the rich and powerful.
- coldtea 9y ago>They're the finance ministers of members country. For them to be there someone has to vote in the respective governments... They don't keep records of what is said there, there is no official voting process, the pressures and blackmails inside the room are kept mum, and the decisions are then carried on. This is not indirect democracy in the sense a parliament of representatives are -- this still has procedures, official records, transparency etc. This is having your representatives participate in behind-closed-doors deals, and then present decisions taken in them as fait accompli.
- oblio 9y agoI'd want the source of your quote first ;)
- pavlov 9y agoOk, I see what you mean. The fundamental problem is that the Euro group doesn't officially exist as a separate unit within the EU. The constitutional agreements of the Union essentially pretend that all member states are also automatically members of the currency union... But obviously this is not the case, because so many members either opted out or haven't yet been admitted into the Euro. Since the informal Euro group has no official function, its power is executed through whatever decisions the finance ministers can push forward in their home countries. Should the meetings' minutes be public? I think so. But it's not clear to me where to draw the line. If the finance minister of Germany calls the finance minister of Italy, we don't expect a public transcript. If there are a few more counterparts on the conference call, same thing. What are the criteria for when it becomes an official meeting of an inofficial body?