2 ms·
I think part of the explanation is cultural changes over time. The EU is very much a symbol of internationalism/globalism, even if localised into a continental
by skissane 9y ago
I think part of the explanation is cultural changes over time. The EU is very much a symbol of internationalism/globalism, even if localised into a continental context, while Brexit is a nationalistic rebellion against it. Nationalism was more popular/accepted in the past (especially so for British nationalism), so older people tend to be more sympathetic to nationalism, and hence more likely to support Brexit. Whereas, I think the popular culture is moving away from nationalism and towards internationalism/globalism instead. (Not universally – subgroups like the alt right are moving in the other direction, but they are a minority.) Part of that move is no doubt due to the Internet, which helps people see themselves as part of one planet by interacting with people in other countries on a regular basis. Teenagers watching YouTube are just as likely to watch videos from other countries as their own (provided they understand the language), which is accelerating the process of global unification of popular culture which the media and entertainment industries had already begun. But these sorts of cultural changes always effect the younger people the most, whereas older people are more likely to retain cultural outlooks prevalent when they were younger. The young are naturally a leading indicator of social and cultural change, the old a trailing indicator of it.
(It is more complicated in that a lot of younger people can be positive about globalist/internationalist institutions such as the EU and the UN over nation-states, yet also often quite sympathetic to separatist nationalisms such as those of Scotland, Catalonia, the Basque country, Kosovo, Palestine, Kurdistan, Tibet, West Papua, etc. To some extent that seems contradictory, and the idealist tendency of the young to support the underdog may explain that contradiction; on the other hand, to support regional nationalisms can be in a way anti-nationalistic, in that supporting smaller nationalisms against larger ones (e.g. Scottish nationalism against British nationalism, Basque/Catalan nationalism against Spanish nationalism) can be seen as consistent with a broader anti-nationalist outlook–one can foresee a future for Europe in which the existing nation-states are sucked away simultaneously in both directions, upward by the growth in power of the EU and downward by devolutionist and secessionist movements (that are hopeful that the structures of the EU might make their devolutionist or secessionist projects easier and more successful.))
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 9y agoI think your "cultural change" explanation is a major factor, but there also appears to be a strong tendency for the issues the old tend to find themselves most heavily aligned against the young and most outspoken about to be those driven heavily by emotional appeal over reason. It isn't superior ability to separate facts from emotion, use of experience to inform their decisions or greater compassion that's making older people disproportionately likely to believe things like Birtherism and creationism, disbelieve things like climate change and immigrants being net contributors to the economy and find the idea their offspring might marry outside their race objectionable. Brexit is far from the best example of this kind of divide, but even there it's noticeable that the Remain campaign focused its appeal on financial benefits, respected authorities' opinions and perceived negotiating power for better international arrangements whilst the Leave campaign talked about immigrants, authorities being "elites" and linking perceived "control" to nationhood and borders. (Admittedly the Remain campaign was neither effective nor targeted at the very youngest, but there was a marked difference in strategy. And it's also an example of where the older generation weren't so much clinging to a belief held in their youth as actively changing their mind) I mean, to give the old their due, they're probably less susceptible to becoming members of fully-fledged personality cults than the young, and it's not as if progressive sentiments are invariably driven by reasoned consideration, but one can't help suspecting that if the old were truly wiser, their objections to certain cultural changes wouldn't manifest itself in disproportionate willingness to subscribe to nonsense like Birtherism.