4 ms·
The result of computing leaving the hands of heavily-technical users and entering the world of the non-technical is that people are terrified of doing the wrong
by kelnos 9y ago
The result of computing leaving the hands of heavily-technical users and entering the world of the non-technical is that people are terrified of doing the wrong thing and breaking things.
Technical people inherently know that there's very little they can do that's irreversible, and that they'll be able to figure out how to reverse even the craziest of breakage.
Non-technical people do not assume breakage is irreversible, and even when they do, they do not assume that they'll be able to unbreak it themselves. Finding someone to help is a nuisance and can be embarrassing.
- KGIII 9y agoMaybe if they had to struggle, they'd learn? If we old people could do it, the next generation is smart enough to do it. Hell, they've got Google to help them. It's not like I'm expecting a return of dip switches and multi-binder manuals. Just, maybe, stop designing for the lowest common denominator? People aren't going to learn unless you give them a reason to. People aren't going to learn if they don't have to. Would you rather smarter users, or simplistic software that underperforms and offers only one output option? I favor choice. I do admit that it makes good financial choice to cater to the lowest common denominator, but even many of my beloved Linux apps are getting dumbed down. I haven't even had a kernel panic in years. Hell, I haven't even had to compile my own kernel in this whole decade. (I have, I just didn't need to.) It's not about keeping it out of the hands of the less technical, it's about still keeping it educational for those of us who are. What kind of dystopia is it, when the preferences menu has but three options? Instead of a stylus, maybe you should just give me a crayon! Really, I think VLC has it right. Handbrake is pretty good. Gimp goes a bit overboard, but I can respect that. My VNC server? It's got like eight options, total. Torrent client? Maybe twice that many, spread over four panes. That's like putting four pieces of lettuce on four plates and telling me it's a salad! Mobile apps? Some of them don't even have options! If there are no options, why use an app? Just use the web! Hell, they don't even have a close option, some of them. What if I want to close it and restart it at the default screen? Task manager or reboot, that's what. 'Snot like it has a discernable back button. No options to configure it, either. I think people with mental handicaps should be allowed to use computers, just like everyone else. It doesn't mean you should design with them as your primary target audience. I'm pretty sure it took more work to take the buttons out than it took to leave them in there. I can't even begin to count the number of updates that have removed options. What the hell was that? You worked harder to make the application do less. I don't even understand that mentality. Sorry for the rant but this is a pet peeve. Imma start a Bring Back The Buttons campaign. It extends to other things, too. I noticed a friend's new television. Their remote had 3 buttons on it. It wasn't even broken, it came like that from the factory.
- p_l 9y agoThere's even a specific concept in UX research related to that whose name escapes me at the moment, but generally boils to "discoverable interface" that is also open and encouraging the user to explore. This way you aren't "blocked" when you first open the application - but you're encouraged to learn and become expert.
- pdkl95 9y agoThat isn't an argument for removing options or a "simpler" UI (which is usually a euphemism for "inflexible", "fewer features/capabilities"). Yes, non-technical people are often reluctant to experiment due to fears about breaking something. The solution to this problem is to have very clear boundaries around anything that actually does cause irreversible changes (or other "important" actions) while designing the rest of the UI in a way that emphasizes - explicitly, if necessary - that everything is ephemeral. Having a very clear boundary between "safe for experimentation" and anything permanent/important is the most important part. People will learn to experiment if you explain that nothing will be saved until they press the visually distinct "Save Changes") button. When relevant, explain they can use the clearly marked "reload"/"reset" button to return to the original ("fixed") version, so they have a reason to feal safe experimenting. "Magic"/"DWIM" interfaces and functionally overloaded UI features undermine confidence that experimenting is "safe", because they are hard to predict.
- vertex-four 9y agoThe problem is that for some significant amount of users, they don't have the mental model to differentiate between running stuff in an Administrator prompt and playing about with their Word settings - one of them being dangerous and one of them not. We'd have to go right back to OS design principles in the first place to teach people that computers are not terrifying behemoths that are about to fall over at any given second, and then maybe that would follow through into our apps - but as it stands, they come with the default expectation that anything they do might result in needing to call IT. Funnily enough, ChromeOS gets that more-or-less right. There's barely anything you can do to a ChromeOS machine that makes it unusable, and nearly everything is ephemeral. Then you have the always-revertible settings in Google's web apps, and people love it.
- jpindar 9y agoSo hide the advanced options, like Firefox and its about:config. Even ask the user to solve some technical puzzle (hex math, perhaps) to prove they are worthy.