2 ms·
That's exactly what I was wondering about, and here's the answer. I love HN! So from the article: > Black holes [merging] produce gravitational waves but not
by mirimir 9y ago
That's exactly what I was wondering about, and here's the answer. I love HN!
So from the article:
> Black holes [merging] produce gravitational waves but not light.
So really, if you were orbiting such a pair of about-to-merge black holes, the gravitational waves produced by the merger would cause just nm-scale fluctuations?
Also, 1 AU seems awfully close to a pair of orbiting ~25 solar-mass black holes. I skimmed the paper, and didn't see anything about how the orbital distance evolved, leading up to the merger. One could probably calculate that from the mass and spin estimates, it's over my head. So maybe, at 1 AU, the about-to-merge black holes would look effectively like a point mass. Anyone want to venture a guess?
- jessriedel 9y agoIn principle you could have a two black holes orbiting each other in a region otherwise devoid of matter, but in practice there is usually a large amount of matter being heated to extreme temperatures in their vicinity. So, optically, it would look very dramatic even if the bare BHs don't emit light. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_disk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_disk A 25 solar-mass BH is about 150km in diameter, and the gravitational waves emitted won't be appreciable until the two BHs had spiraled inward to a separation of a few hundred km. You would need to be roughly 1,000 km away to experience a 1% strain during the merger https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/235285/how-strong-were-the-gravitational-waves-that-ligo-detected-at-the-source https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/235285/how-stron... I don't think spin is important at the order-of-magnitude level (for naturally occuring BHs).
- mirimir 9y agoThanks. Would the radiation at 1 AU from such an accretion disk be harder on an Earth-like planet than that from our Sun? I'm guessing that it would at least be far more variable, given dependence on mass flow. And perhaps skewed toward gamma and other bad stuff.
- jessriedel 9y agoWay outside my field so I can't tell you about variability, but BH accretion disks are definitely hotter and emit intense x-rays and other nasty stuff.