3 ms·
Unfortunately, the development of agriculture and civilization are usually conflated to mean the same thing: people predominantly contrast pre-agricultural, pre
by jcranmer 9y ago
Unfortunately, the development of agriculture and civilization are usually conflated to mean the same thing: people predominantly contrast pre-agricultural, pre-civilization peoples against agricultural, civilized peoples. This causes confusions when people cite instances of agricultural, non-civilized peoples to support claims on one side or the other (I'm unaware of any examples of non-agricultural, civilized states; the closest examples I can think of are still nomadic or semi-nomadic pastoralists, which is still agricultural even if the reliance is on domesticated animals instead of plants).
Also unfortunately, it's hard to know which to prescribe the "problems" and the "benefits" of the agricultural and civilization complex to, agriculture or civilization. The existence of things like specialization and war are hard to find unambiguous evidence for in archaeology (it can sometimes be hard to remember that there are multiple plausible explanations for a find, and picking a certain interpretation may more reflect an archaeologist's biases than the actual truth), and so figuring out when in the course of human development they first appear is difficult if not impossible. I'm generally of the opinion that most of the problems postdate the development of agriculture, but I hold that position less because there's strong evidence for it, but because there's no strong evidence either way and I find it more useful to get other people to consider multiple interpretations of the matter.
- sifar 9y agoThis was posted in one of the threads a few days back. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nLKHYHmPbo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nLKHYHmPbo Starting at 12:00, Toby Hemenway talks about agriculture led industrial culture & its problems. How we are missing a spot where horticulture can be long-term beneficial.