4 ms·
> I'd be living mostly outside, shivering, wondering if I could get enough food to live through the winter I'm not particularly well-versed on hunter-gatherer
by jcranmer 9y ago
> I'd be living mostly outside, shivering, wondering if I could get enough food to live through the winter
I'm not particularly well-versed on hunter-gatherer societies in this regard, especially in Paleolithic societies rather than those that persisted to the modern day. But given that hunter-gatherers were generally nomadic and had a much more diverse source of foods than settled agriculturalists, you probably would have worried less about food lasting you through winter than if you had been in any agricultural civilization up until 100 years ago or so.
> would have little hope of living past 40
Lolnope. Hunter-gatherer societies had longer lifespans than sedentary agriculturists, and even the shortest-lived societies generally had life expectancies of over 50 years of age if you made it past 5 or so.
> I'd suffer from routine episodes of famine, backbreaking labor,
Once again, hunter-gatherers are probably more resistant to famine than settled agriculturalists. It is now well-known that hunter-gatherers spent very little time working: about 2-4 hours per day of work was required, far less even than modern society.
> and the tribe booting me out to die when I was no longer carrying my weight.
Probably not. Old people hold valuable knowledge, such as which foods are edible in extreme famine.
> I'd watch most of my children die young, and would fear all sorts of stupid mythical boogeymen.
Fewer on both accounts than you would in early settled agricultural societies.
While it used to be thought that agriculture was obviously superior to hunter-gatherer societies (not least because it was independently developed at least 9 times), more recent anthropological work has shown that on nearly every metric, hunter-gatherer societies outperform agricultural societies until about the 19th century.
- dorchadas 9y ago> Fewer on both accounts than you would in early settled agricultural societies. Especially because they had fewer children, since the human child is dependent on the mother for so long. So they focused more on getting each child to an age where they could start to take care of themselves before having another one. And it also helped keep population low, which slowed the spread of disease and parasites, and also meant that a smaller food supply could feed people well.
- WalterBright 9y ago> Probably not. "Traditional nomadic tribes often end up abandoning their elderly during their unrelenting travels. The choice for the healthy and young is to do this or carry the old and infirm on their backs — along with children, weapons and necessities — through perilous territory. Also prone to sacrificing their elderly are societies that suffer periodic famines. Citing a dramatic example, Diamond said Paraguay’s Aché Indians assign certain young men the task of killing old people with an ax or spear, or burying them alive." http://newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/jared-diamond-on-aging-150571 http://newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/jared-diamond-on-aging-1505... If you want to lop off 30 years of life expectancy to join your tribe, please include me out.
- jcranmer 9y agoJared Diamond is considered in the anthropological field as about as knowledgeable on anthropology as Donald Trump is on economic and foreign policy. It's also worth pointing out that modern hunter-gatherer societies are not Paleolithic hunter-gatherer societies. Those that remain today generally do so in part because the land they travel is too marginal for intensive agriculture, for example.
- WalterBright 9y agoConsider the quote - how do you suggest a nomadic tribe deal with elderly who cannot walk? I've also seen other historians talk about nomadic tribes leaving the old behind to die, it's just that Diamond came up first in a search.
- nikdaheratik 9y agoAnd there were a number of other societies that didn't do anything like that because they didn't need to move around as much. Especially the ones in Africa, the Middle East, and the other places that were in very fertile locations. Like many of these pop-anthropology and evolutionary psych people, they seem to ignore how useful people in their 50s-60s can be to small groups, especially for things like child care. Other dangers and just the toll of harsher environments did much more to lower the life expectancy than ritualized murder of old people.