4 ms·
Great to see this continuing to make headlines. Given that food science seems like a relatively small field, and Dr. Wansink one of its few giants, it seemed li
by danso 9y ago
Great to see this continuing to make headlines. Given that food science seems like a relatively small field, and Dr. Wansink one of its few giants, it seemed like this was going to be a niche scandal that died down over time from apathy, despite the massive pattern of glaring errors, which are apparent even without access to the original data. I wonder how noticeable this scandal would still be had it not involved government funding.
One of the more amazing things about it was how it started with Dr. Wansink writing a personal blog post [1] that was meant to advise and inspire struggling students on how to get their PhDs. His message was basically "never say no" to doing extra work, and he described a student who worked hard to produce 5 peer-reviewed papers using the data from a previous "self-funded, failed" study. Wansink would still be venerated today if he hadn't decided to blog that day.
[1] http://archive.is/cPxmm http://archive.is/cPxmm
- SilasX 9y ago>His message was basically "never say no" to doing extra work, and he described a student who worked hard to produce 5 peer-reviewed papers using the data from a previous "self-funded, failed" study. Wansink would still be venerated today if he hadn't decided to blog that day What do you mean? The article reports him doing a lot of unethical stuff after that, I don't see why "not making that blog post" would have saved him from derision.
- sfifs 9y agothe implication is people really started digging into his work after reading that blog post.
- danso 9y agoThe studies that are currently under scrutiny were conducted well before he wrote the blog post. All of the errors and methodologies that have come to light had always been visible.
- norgie 9y agoThe blog post basically encouraged students to engage in p-hacking (take data from failed studies and find something interesting in it!), which caused other researchers to critically review the methodology and statistics in those papers and then all of his other papers
- randycupertino 9y agoI remember hearing about this guy when he got into his initial twitter war when the other researchers called out his shoddy methods. Who knew there was so much drama around food science! I guess when it's such a niche field there isn't much scrutiny for the subject matter experts.
- mercer 9y agoSadly indications are strong that this is not just a problem in a niche field. As I understand it, the problem is not even just limited to the social sciences (although it might be a bigger problem there).