4 ms·
Wow. This is everything that's wrong with science and the science-policy interface today. >Brian Wansink of Cornell University publishes headline-friendly stu
by SilasX 9y ago
Wow. This is everything that's wrong with science and the science-policy interface today.
>Brian Wansink of Cornell University publishes headline-friendly studies about food psychology and oversees a $22 million federally funded program that uses his research to promote “smarter lunchrooms” in nearly 30,000 schools.
Yep, the same problem as with the food pyramid: using a small amount of evidence to justify a massive intervention into a complex system. The way it should work is, the bigger the change you want to make to a system, the better your model needs to be.
Deploying it to 30,000 schools? The results need to be solid enough to be in textbooks, not something the researcher is still actively working on.
>His experiments have found, for example, that women who put cereal on their kitchen counters weigh more than those who don’t, and that people will pour more wine if they’re holding the glass than if it's sitting on a table. Over the past two decades he’s written two popular books and more than 100 research papers, and enjoyed widespread media coverage (including on BuzzFeed[1]).
The overhyped, small-effect-size, never-replicated studies that even Kahneman[2] admits to, about subtle environment impacts on behavior.
>Yet over the past year, Wansink and his “Food and Brand Lab” have come under fire from scientists and statisticians who’ve spotted all sorts of red flags — including data inconsistencies, mathematical impossibilities, errors, duplications, exaggerations, eyebrow-raising interpretations, and instances of self-plagiarism — in 50 of his studies.
Another thing you should check for before rolling out to 30k schools.
>Both studies claimed that children are more likely to choose fruits and vegetables when they’re jazzed up, such as when carrots are called “X-Ray Vision Carrots” and when apples have Sesame Street stickers.
Cool, so more misconceptions we have to correct when kids grow up. ("No, carrots won't give you x-ray vision.")
>Almost 30,000 schools have adopted those techniques, and the government pays each one up to $2,000 for doing so.
Another problem: public schools being such cheap dates.
[1] Props to clickbait-hungry Buzzfeed for noting that they got affected by the frenzy.
[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15228712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15228712
- shpx 9y agoThe belief that eating carrots improves night vision is a myth stemming from propaganda used by the Royal Air Force during the Second World War to explain why their pilots had improved success during night air battles, but was actually used to disguise advances in radar technology and the use of red lights on instrument panels. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrot#Night_vision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrot#Night_vision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_common_misconceptions#Nutrition.2C_food.2C_and_drink https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_common_misconceptions#...
- goialoq 9y ago> Finally, this photo of Brian Wansink does not favor the hypothesis "rigorous scientist" over scam artist: Ironically, as you attempt to takedown a biased scientist, your own biases are showing.
- SilasX 9y agoFair enough; that's a weak point and there's so much better evidence. I'll remove it.
- merraksh 9y ago> Finally, this photo of Brian Wansink does not favor the hypothesis "rigorous scientist" over scam artist: > https://img.buzzfeed.com/buzzfeed-static/static/2017-09/27/1.. https://img.buzzfeed.com/buzzfeed-static/static/2017-09/27/1.... Maybe, but it also favors the impression that he is good at outreach, which is a plus to any academician and probably essential for his type of work.
- timb07 9y agoI think it only points out a problem with the science-policy interface. Science has correctly identified that dodgy results were being published, and they're being retracted. Ideally peer review would have picked up those problems before publication, but this is the next best thing.