3 ms·
A system full of smart people with no effective opposition is too unstable, in the physics sense of the term. It's too easy for the system to go flying off in s
by jerf 16y ago
A system full of smart people with no effective opposition is too unstable, in the physics sense of the term. It's too easy for the system to go flying off in some really, really bad direction with nobody stopping it, because all the smart people have rationalized that this is a good idea and the negative consequences will come far too late. (And smart people are just as vulnerable to the argument "The bad things are happening because our ideas haven't been implemented hard enough, so the solution is to do the same thing, only more!" If I could just wipe one argument from political discourse, that's probably the one I'd pick....) If you need to see government where intellectuals of one sort or another were in uncontested control of the government, the 20th century can provide you with some examples. You probably won't like them.
The real key to good government (and the brilliance of the founding fathers) has actually been to effectively cripple the government and make sure nobody has the power to completely rewrite the government on a whim, and that no coalition that is capable of doing so can last very long. Unfortunately, that still seems to only delay the inevitable, but that's better than nothing.