4 ms·
"But Mr. Anderson, how can your punishment be cruel and unusual... if you are not actually... being... punished?" The Supreme Court has ruled that lifetime sex
by bitwize 9y ago
"But Mr. Anderson, how can your punishment be cruel and unusual... if you are not actually... being... punished?"
The Supreme Court has ruled that lifetime sex offender registration, despite few demonstrable positive effects on sex offender rehabilitation or sex offense prevention and despite their only apparent goal being the unpersoning of people who commit certain offenses, does not transgress the Eight Amendment because the sex offender registries are a "public safety" measure, not an actual punishment. Doubtless they will do the same for something like this.
- Fnoord 9y agoAh, "public safety" measure. The naming & shaming is a byproduct or unforeseen consequence. The military calls such "collateral damage". What is the purpose of such database? It falls or stands on recidivism. If there is a way (e.g. medical cocktail) where the chance of recidivism is close enough to 0 just like the average civilian there's no practical need for any "special" register. This stands on the premise that the sex offender actively uses their medical cocktail as prescribed.