4 ms·
These devices all ride on your own personal network. Their traffic is easy to monitor for timing and size of the data transmitted outward. If you are worried
by slg 9y ago
These devices all ride on your own personal network. Their traffic is easy to monitor for timing and size of the data transmitted outward. If you are worried about spying you might put a piece of tape over your webcam, but I can't say I have heard of anyone physically disabling their laptop's microphone. These voice assistants are basically the same security threat as those open microphones on your laptop. Both of them are still less dangerous than a smartphone that has its own network connection and can more easily hide its spying.
- infecto 9y agoMany people physically disable their laptops microphone. Some people in my office do and I think the most famous case is Zuckerberg. https://boygeniusreport.files.wordpress.com/2016/06/mark-zuckerberg-tapes-macbook-camera-mic-2.jpg?quality=98&strip=all&w=782 https://boygeniusreport.files.wordpress.com/2016/06/mark-zuc...
- Sargos 9y agoThe difference being someone might actually care about what Zuckerberg is saying.
- infecto 9y agoAnd? I was simply refuting the comment "..I can't say I have heard of anyone physically disabling their laptop's microphone". I know people who do this, not just Zuckerberg.
- slg 9y agoPutting tape over a microphone doesn't physically disable it. People have been able to get audio out of a room by watching the vibrating of windows or simulate a key logger by listening to the sounds a keyboard makes. If you are worried about being actively spied upon, nothing short of physically disconnecting the microphone is 100% secure.
- r00fus 9y agoJust because you can monitor the traffic doesn't mean you can verify what it's sending. If the assistant is designed properly, it'll be using pinned certs and everything it can do to encrypt and compress the data, but to be usable it's probably listening and throwing away a lot of data to be responsive (like how the new iPhone cameras constantly capture when on, and give you appropriate moment right before you press). There is a possibility that additional trigger phrases may exist that Amazon/Google/etc capture. It might be rare enough to be difficult to trace. I wonder what data was handed over in that Echo subpoena for the murder case? http://www.cnn.com/2017/03/07/tech/amazon-echo-alexa-bentonville-arkansas-murder-case/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2017/03/07/tech/amazon-echo-alexa-bentonv...
- slg 9y agoYes, you can't tell what it being transferred. But knowing when and how much it is transferring shows that it isn't actively listening to everything. If you are worried about companies like Amazon and Google lying about what these devices use as wake words, why would you trust Google, Apple, or Microsoft that they don't lie about the same thing regarding your phone or laptop? That is my main problem with these arguments regarding voice assistants. These devices are really just a microphone and an internet connection. They are no more a tool of Big Brother than your phone, computer, TV, Xbox, or any other device with a microphone and internet connection. In fact, many of those devices can do a better job of hiding their compromised status.
- r00fus 9y agoThere is an option: Don't use voice assistants. That's my option. I trust Apple (and Google for the few devices in my home) to not be listening persistently when they say they don't. I don't enable Hey Google, Hey Siri. That could be naive but as you said you have to trust at some point (even if it's the compiler or hardware). I can disable hardware at the USB bus level on my MacBooks and other generic OS - I don't use microphones on them anyway. If you really distrust you can wire a headphone in and disable that. Persistent voice recognition is a rubicon I don't want crossed in my home. It's a "feature" I don't think is needed. DONOTWANT is a signal I want to send to the market, fwiw, by not buying these devices.