14 ms·
Pretty awesome, nice to see they confirmation with Virgo. I realize that I've never really considered what it would be like to be 'near' (say a few 10's of tho
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Pretty awesome, nice to see they confirmation with Virgo.
I realize that I've never really considered what it would be like to be 'near' (say a few 10's of thousands of light years away) from an event like this. With all that energy, at what level would it pulverize a planetary body?
- sandworm101 9y agoNothing. If it happened that close you would still feel/see nothing. These detectors are seeing movements far smaller than the width of a proton. A planet would have to be orbiting one of these binaries to be close enough to potentially feel much of anything.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- exhilaration 9y agoWell the x-rays and gamma rays would kill you if you were close. Aren't those released when these events happen?
- sandworm101 9y agoYes but there are plenty of more likely events that emit those. The merger of two BHs is special for the gravity waves it generates. Rays can also be blocked given enough mass, gravity waves no.
- gajomi 9y agoI was about to reply the same based on a naive Fermi estimation argument concerning the energy density three solar masses distributed equally over a shell with thickness proportional to the effective width of the pulse. But I wonder, what would be the actually mechanism that would break up a planetary body? Would sufficiently strong grativitational waves at wavelengths smaller than the planet be able to stress/shear enough to cause a breakup? Or is there some kind of gravity/gravity interaction that would be needed?
- raattgift 9y agoIt's not so much nothing, as practically nothing. The main issue is that the gravitational waves only couple with you (or rather your microscopic bits) very slightly. If you get close enough (~ 10^2-10^4 GW wavelengths depending on the system) then you have several sensory systems that in principle could -- with some awkward assumptions about signal transduction in the middle of some even more awkward changes of gauge -- produce something noticeable. The principal problem is that while a cell at one end of your body may move noticeably compared to a cell at the other end of your body from the perspective of someone watching a cell in the middle of your body, these three cells don't move around much with respect to their neighbouring cells, and the "guts" of each cell move around even less with respect to the cellular membranes. Some senses rely on groups of cells moving with respect to one another; some rely on intracellular activity alone. There is the possibility of a small slosh in your inner ears, where there are some structures that are exquisitely responsive to small strains; that might make you nauseous, or it might trigger an episode of tinnitus. It might also go unnoticed. That close to the merger you're likely to be vaporized by non-gravitational radiation, though. ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15352994 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15352994 ) Finally I think intuitions break down before you get to the near field regime, and nobody can really tell you what to expect within a couple of wavelengths of the source of the gravitational radiation even some time before the merger. Certainly linearized gravity fails to produce gravitational waves thanks to an explosion of non-linearities. You can only really say that the dynamical spacetime is even more full of distortions in that regime. Unfortunately if we had a purely linear gravity in reality (i.e., if gravity wasn't itself a source of gravity), it is also the regime where one would expect several human senses would be obviously stimulated.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoIt depends on the gradient. The fundamental nature of the force that rips you apart during spaghettification is exactly the same. And you would definitely feel that one. It all boils down to how strong the distortion is at one extreme of your body, versus the opposite extreme. If it's about the same, you won't feel it. If the difference is sizable, you would feel it to some extent. If it's very large, it's a meat grinder.
- orf 9y agoWell I never: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghettification https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghettification
- sandworm101 9y agoThese two BHs just merged. So they have been spinning around each other for a few million years already. Anything close enough for spagetification to be an option would have been tossed away long before the final merger.
- bkanber 9y agoRelativity of simultaneity. Different observers not agreeing on when things happen is a built-in trait of the universe. In our reference frame, those things only just got spaghettified.
- rcthompson 9y agoI wonder what it would feel like to be in a gravitational wave that was strong enough to feel but not strong enough to tear the planet to pieces. I've been in an earthquake before, and my best point of reference for that was that it felt a lot like standing on a boat as it rocked back and forth. Would this feel the same?
- 52-6F-62 9y agoThat's an interesting analogue if it's accurate. I never thought I would see waves flowing through a granite flooring until I experience a level 4 or 5 earthquake in a mid-century building. My brain couldn't register what was occurring at first.
- PoachedSausage 9y agoWe don't get many or very powerful earthquakes in the UK, but once I was working in the loft of a house near the epicentre of one, you could see the beams move in wave.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoI'm in Toronto, and we don't either. It is nothing less than surreal.
- gajomi 9y agoEDIT: I just realized you were talking about a hypothetical wave, and not the particular one here, so my comment below doesn't actually address your question :) I am not an astrophysicist, but was also wondering the same thing. Gravitational waves move at the speed of light. Here is a graph showing the wavelength of gravitational waves from various sources http://www.tapir.caltech.edu/~teviet/Waves/gwave_spectrum.html http://www.tapir.caltech.edu/~teviet/Waves/gwave_spectrum.ht... The Ligo sensitivity range is about 10^6 meters. The speed of light is about 3*10^8 m/s. So peak to trough a few hundred per second. Much higher frequency than earthquake.
- 9y ago
- contravariant 9y agoThis event was 1.8 billion (10^9) light years away. The so called "strain" (i.e. the extent to which the wave stretches / compresses things) is around 10^-20 or somewhere around that order of magnitude. To make things dangerous I reckon you'll need to have a strain on the order of 1, and since strain is inversely proportional to distance that would give a distance of 10^-11 ly, or around 100 km. Which is not a 'safe' distance to a black hole in any scenario.
- eponeponepon 9y agoWould that be 100km from the event horizon, or from the singularity?
- contravariant 9y agoWell the estimate kind of assumes a point source, but at 100km from the merger that assumption is probably no longer accurate. You'll need to simulate the black hole merger to figure out where exactly it would be unsafe, but it looks like it would be distance that's pretty unsafe even without the merger.
- raattgift 9y agoIt's possibly more interesting to think in terms of $\nabla_\mu T^{\mu\nu} = 0$ which is the generalized conservation of stress-energy-momentum, and to think in terms of energy-momentum entering and exiting regions of spacetime. The gravitational radiation carries momentum out of a (comfortably flat-ish at the boundary) region of spacetime tightly enclosing the inspirallers and merger, and delivers momentum elsewhere in the inspiraller's forward light cone. In an otherwise expanding vacuum solution, the radiated momentum just propagates to future null infinity. Since we have other matter in our universe, the gravitational radiation can donate some of the original momentum to matter outside our chosen region, causing bits of matter along a lightlike path to move a small amount (or if you want to switch to an energy picture, ordinary matter outside our chosen region will become a tiny bit hotter upon feeling the gravitational radiation). Although the amount of stress-energy-momentum radiated out of our region comprising the inspirallers is enormous (and at peak is so brief that the power is almost unimaginably enormous), the coupling of gravitational radiation to matter is extremely weak, so there will be very little scattering or absorption by matter outside the region. Consequently, most of the momentum crossing to the outside of our Schwarzschild-like boundary around the merger will still go to future null infinity. It's this weak coupling that leads to your intuition about a human having to be very close to the merger itself in order to feel anything noticeable from the gravitational radiation. By comparison one would expect balding to happen so that we recover a no-hair state from the merged BH, and there are decent reasons to expect more than gravitational radiation to be shed during balding. Additionally the individual BHs may have a lot of energetic particles entrained around them, and much of that will be moving on geodesics conducive to extremely high energy interactions (think of a pair of BHs whose rotational axes are parallel but with each BH dragging its accretion disc in the opposite CW/CCW direction, and we can add in extreme inverse Compton scattering just prior to contact as the photon rings around each BH interact relativistically with charged particles around the other). And of course this picture is likely to be much more dramatic in the case of an NS-BH merger. Another way of thinking about this is that the build-up of momentum due to gravitational interactions is typically slow (and steady) but may have no upper limit, and that's the source of danger rather than a quick (and briefly high amplitude) gravitational interaction that doesn't take away more than a few percent of the built-up momentum of the matter at and near the source of the burst of gravitational radiation. A human being close enough to the merger to feel the effects of gravitational radiation is thus likely to be feeling an awful lot more from excitations in the non-gravitational fields, or alternatively, the nearby human being is at risk of collision with ultrarelativistic (i.e., ultra-high-momentum) matter.
- nerfhammer 9y agohttps://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/338912/how-would-a-passing-gravitational-wave-look-or-feel https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/338912/how-would...
- vmware513 9y agoMove to Wellington, New Zealand. You will feel the gravitational waves/shakes every day. ;) This is like a new JS framework release, happening so often, you don't care it anymore. ;)
- sleavey 9y agoThis is only the beginning of the excitement. There's loads more stuff out there that LIGO and Virgo can see - binary neutron star inspirals being the big one.
- jessriedel 9y agoScott Aaronson estimated the strain if you were 1 AU away from one of the previous BH mergers detected by LIGO and found you would only be stretched by about 50 nm (about a thousandth the width of a human hair). So you'd need to be very close indeed to feel something. http://www.businessinsider.com/what-gravitational-wave-feels-like-2016-2 http://www.businessinsider.com/what-gravitational-wave-feels... http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2651 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=2651 The alternative take is that LIGO's detectors are unfathomably sensitive, detecting when its ~4km arms stretch by just 10^-19 meters. That's a 10,000th the width of a proton, where the proton is just a 100,000th the width of an atom, and the atom is about a 1,000,000th the width of a hair.
- Pyxl101 9y ago> The alternative take is that LIGO's detectors are unfathomably sensitive, detecting when its ~4km arms stretch by just 10^-19 meters. That's a 10,000th the width of a proton, where the proton is just a 100,000th the width of an atom, and the atom is about a 1,000,000th the width of a hair. Wow. Hearing the sensitivity described in those terms is absolutely mind-blowing.
- pedro_hab 9y agoI know right? There is a video on veritasium on how absurd this is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphcyNWFD10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iphcyNWFD10
- StavrosK 9y agoI don't know, I can never process numbers this big. "To understand how sensitive the LIGO is, imagine each arm stretched out as far as the sun. Even if we had the resources to build an object this big, we still would not be able to get people to understand this intuitively at all."
- FeepingCreature 9y agoFor comparison, the Planck length is 10^-35, so another 10^16 smaller again.