3 ms·
And it is based on the simple assumption that we can accumulate debt at any pace forever. Unfortunately I am not convinced it is the case. There is a debt to GD
by cm2187 9y ago
And it is based on the simple assumption that we can accumulate debt at any pace forever. Unfortunately I am not convinced it is the case. There is a debt to GDP ratio where the system will break.
- pjc50 9y agoIs there? Public or private debt? What model do you have that tells us where it is? Yes, if the payments become too onerous or the ability to roll over is compromised (Greece passim), then you have a serious problem, but the whole thing does not magically blow up at a certain level. Also, remember that at a global balance sheet level, debt == savings. Debt (personal+state+corporate) has expanded because there are more and more people saving for their pensions, and the savings glut has pushed down the price of debt. (and the "missing trillions" stashed in tax havens have to be lent out somewhere, too)
- cm2187 9y agoI agree, you can't specify a specific ratio to the second decimal where things will blow up. Greece blew up below where Japan is now. Not the least because it is largely irrational. How much is too much debt? It's when your creditors decide to cancel your credit card. I am not convinced that how that debt is financed will change much. It's really a loss of confidence risk, which like a market downturn is impossible to predict. But you nevertheless just know it will happen and that any incremental indebtedness brings us closer.
- digi_owl 9y agoprivate, as the numbers i have seen is that when private debt hits something like 200% of GDP bad things starts to happen. the crazy part is that it does not even need to be a complete halt in lending that cause it, just enough of a dip that expenses (debt repayments etc) outpace income (from the turnover of existing money plus the money coming in as newly issued loans). And the whole debt equals savings thing is a fallacy that sadly the economics profession has convinced itself is true. The Bank of England released a document a few years back that showed how private lending effectively puts new money into circulation. http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarterlybulletin/2014/qb14q102.pdf http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarte... Funny enough public debt is largely a non-issue, as long as said debt is denominated in the nation's own currency.
- cm2187 9y ago> Funny enough public debt is largely a non-issue, as long as said debt is denominated in the nation's own currency. You seem to imply that money printing, and the resulting inflation, is painless and a non problem. I am not sure I agree with that. Lots of people will suffer in a high inflationary environment. Pensioners to start with.
- digi_owl 9y agoThis suggests that said pensioners only have a fixed, non-interest bearing pool of money to make payments from. If so is the case, something is badly wrong with the society that extends beyond the realm of economics.