9 ms·
"The term ‘Identity Theft’ implies, and its usage accepts, that the person whose identity is being stolen is the victim. They’re almost always not." What. If
by yellowapple 9y ago
"The term ‘Identity Theft’ implies, and its usage accepts, that the person whose identity is being stolen is the victim. They’re almost always not."
What.
If someone uses your information to take advantage of your good credit and get a car loan, then defaults on that loan, guess whose credit score just got hurt? Guess who's going to have a harder time getting a loan for one's own new car?
The whole article stems from the assumption that stealing someone's identity doesn't make that someone a victim. That assumption is blatantly false, and therefore so is pretty much the rest of the article.
Call it what you want, but fraud committed in your name still harms you, and thus still makes you a victim.
- knodi123 9y agoYou're missing the point. Obviously yes your credit score gets hurt, and yes you sometimes have the hassle of recovering money, re-establishing your identity, etc. The entire point of the article is that all these harms are not something the identity thief does to you. They are things that the identity thief does to SOME CORPORATION, and then that corporation passes part of the problem on to you. And the phrase "identity theft" is part of the way of thinking that allows the corporations to justify passing the harm on to you. The short audio clip from Mitchell And Webb that people in here are passing around really explains it best. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CS9ptA3Ya9E
- yellowapple 9y agoYou're missing my point. Just because the person whose identity was stolen was not the direct/intended victim does not mean that said person is not a victim at all.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThe bank is the victim of the crime. The person whose identity was stolen is a victim of the bank's negligence in properly identifying people.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y ago> Call it what you want, but fraud committed in your name still harms you, and thus still makes you a victim. No, it doesn't. If someone comes to you and claims that they are John Smith, and you loan them a thousand bucks, only to discover later that the person who you gave the thousand bucks to actually wasn't John Smith, then you, and you alone, are the victim, and you are out of a thousand bucks. Nothing of this has anything to do with John Smith. Only if you then harass John Smith to pay you a thousand bucks by making fraudulent claims that you loaned him a thousand bucks and tell everyone that John Smith is not credit worthy, then John Smith becomes a victim, specifically a victim of you.
- yellowapple 9y ago"No, it doesn't." Yes, it tangibly and demonstrably does. It means that the process of establishing/asserting your identity is much harder, since now there's someone else running around with the credentials normally used to assert said identity. You now need to spend time and money invalidating whatever credentials you can and hoping that the ones you can't invalidate aren't actually compromised. If someone manages to get your Gmail password and use it to send spam, you're still a victim of cybercrime, even though you weren't necessarily a victim of the spamming. Same thing here. Someone is using your credentials (like SSN and other identifiers) to defraud someone else. Even though you're not the direct victim of that fraud, you're still a victim of identity theft, since your credentials were compromised and used by someone else.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y ago> Yes, it tangibly and demonstrably does. It means that the process of establishing/asserting your identity is much harder, since now there's someone else running around with the credentials normally used to assert said identity. You now need to spend time and money invalidating whatever credentials you can and hoping that the ones you can't invalidate aren't actually compromised. None of that is a harm from the fraud, it's all harm from the bank's unjustified claims . > If someone manages to get your Gmail password and use it to send spam, you're still a victim of cybercrime, even though you weren't necessarily a victim of the spamming. If someone manages to get your gmail password from Google, then Google is the victim of cybercrime. If Google then reacts by closing your account, you are a victim of Google. > Same thing here. Someone is using your credentials (like SSN and other identifiers) to defraud someone else. Even though you're not the direct victim of that fraud, you're still a victim of identity theft, since your credentials were compromised and used by someone else. If you want to call the behavior of the bank (or whatever) in this situation "identity theft", well, sure. Though I would suggest that that is highly misleading. More appropriate terms would be slander or blackmail, maybe?