3 ms·
I'm afraid it just confused me. I'm kinda old, so maybe I'm just too far down the Zuckerberg curve to understand. So, I saw a "trend", I guess, called "World
by SwellJoe 19y ago
I'm afraid it just confused me. I'm kinda old, so maybe I'm just too far down the Zuckerberg curve to understand.
So, I saw a "trend", I guess, called "World Politics" with a picture of Obama bein' cool (like all other pictures of Obama...that dude's definitely got cool down), clicked it, and found...nothing? I mean there was a page there, but there was just a picture of a couple of foreign dudes (World Politics...makes sense I guess) and a random video. And then I felt an overwhelming feeling of, "I want those 30 seconds back".
So, reading the comments here, I'm beginning to grasp the concept of the site, and I now realize why I was so disappointed by the content I saw: It was generated by an idiot user, the most common creature in the known universe. So, the system needs to be better at solving the hard problem of helping idiot users create something useful.
Your site design is nice, if a bit busy.
The "browse" page is a much better overview than your front page, which I found intimidating and confusing. Browse, while it could be mistaken for "just another social news site" is actually comprehensible to me, and makes your site seem more interesting...it also seems to allow the genuinely interesting stuff to rise to the top, so I don't wind up on the nonsensical "World Politics" page that has nothing interesting to look at or read.
I think maybe this is a case where simplifying your application would be a net positive. Easier said than done, I know, as I'm sure every little feature on the site had someone campaigning for it at some point in the devel/beta cycle. But new users show up and see an explosion of confusing concepts and no clear entry point to get involved.
- matthewer 19y agoThis is great feedback. We just redid the homepage, but I totally agree. It is not coming across like I had hoped. Thanks for your comment. Truly appreciated. Can you make any suggestions for what you would like to see on the homepage. How can we make it more clear?
- SwellJoe 19y agoOK, the single biggest problem is there's way too much happening. Do you really need SEVEN tabs for each trend? I can discern no difference between four of them (overview, the pitch, the buzz, in depth)...they all seem pretty much like the same thing. And, if you're a socially generated site, isn't it ALL talk? You should probably have no tabs and a simpler view all-around. If you do have tabs, maybe just "Media" and "Talk" with the first page remaining "Overview". All of that other stuff just seems to just be people making a few random "Yeah, my idea is awesome!" comments. If you want people to have that kind of ownership, maybe let them have personal profile pages where they can just say "Yeah, I'm awesome!" and then let the trends stand alone with just the talk and media. Likewise for the front page..."What's Next?" and "The Wire". I can't even begin to guess what the difference between the two concepts might be. Too much going on, and I'm just confused. But, if your users can make sense of this stuff...maybe I'm just too old. But I'm definitely very confused, and often irritated about not finding the interesting bits easily. As I mentioned, the Browse page is actually pretty cool...and made me want to click through. But once I clicked, I regretted it, as I didn't find what I wanted to find on the other side. (Partly because idiot users are not interesting, and partly because I was just overwhelmed by the number of links off to nothing...one can more safely assume that half of the tabs will lead to empty pages than that they are worth clicking.)