8 ms·
Regardless of what you call it, the fact that someone using your information to take out loans and signing all sorts of contracts should never be your problem.
by mrweasel 9y ago
Regardless of what you call it, the fact that someone using your information to take out loans and signing all sorts of contracts should never be your problem.
If a credit card company issues a card in your name to someone else, then clearly they didn't do their verification properly.
It should be possible to have all your personal information floating around and still be certain that no one can use that information for anything. I'm pretty sure it works for Sweden where their SSN aren't secret, nor are addresses or phone numbers.
Sure that may mean that you need to show up in the bank, or have a secure government authentication method, but that's not beyond implementation.
- LeifCarrotson 9y ago> that's not beyond implementation It may be in the US. Because of Revelation 13:16-17: "16 And he causeth all, both small and great, rich and poor, free and bond, to receive a mark in their right hand, or in their foreheads; 17 And that no man might buy or sell, save he that had the mark, or the name of the beast, or the number of his name." That's why national ID is difficult to sell here. Sorry.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoYou seem to be under the impression that the national ID in Sweden is in the form of some kind of tattoo?
- scotty79 9y ago> receive a mark in their right hand I guess if you got your ID by picking it up with your right hand it still is the mark of the beast.
- brlewis 9y agoI don't think mrweasel's comment was proposing national ID as a solution to "identity theft". It was just positing that solutions must exist other than keeping identifying information secret.
- mcdonje 9y agoI thought barcodes are already the mark of the beast. https://www.wired.com/2012/12/upc-mark-of-the-beast/ https://www.wired.com/2012/12/upc-mark-of-the-beast/
- 0xfeba 9y agoThen it was RFIDs, then Obamacare, then... God's perfect wisdom just keeps getting lost in translation, what a shame!
- cat199 9y agoYet bank accounts typically require at least a copy of state-issued ID to open, all without national ID! Part of the resistance to national ID is also a question of federalism - we do not officially have a 'national government' - we have a 'federal government', even though in practice it is hardly federal anymore.
- turk184 9y agoThe Real ID Act establishes a national identity whether we want to admit it or not--states have to knuckle under. That the Federal Gov doesn't have some central database doesn't make it any less of a de facto national ID. Also, now that you must have one to fly (or a passport) we're inching ever closer to that police state. I didn't have to be this way--we can see from the Equifax and OPM incidents that all this data aggregation is as dangerous as anything else. I support aviation security, but not all the big government, police state add-ons that are there mainly to increase the profits of major political donor corporations.
- jmcs 9y agoYou don't need national ID if every state issues a real ID document. There's no European wide ID but national IDs of all EU countries are accepted everywhere by law and it works.
- zxcmx 9y agoWell shit thats what peope don't get. You accept a shitty system that kinda works or a national system that works super well that looks like modern fascism with good biometrics. Choose your poison. Carefully.
- zanny 9y agoSince when is providing a way to identify people facism? This isn't the 18th century. Economics are global. You cannot just use the fact you've known the shopkeep your whole life as an authentication service. Either we have a good functioning way to uniquely identify people or we don't. If you have the former, you could use it for evil, in much the same way as how with the later it is used for evil a lot with the various frauds talked about in the OP. If the government wants to do evil it will do so with or without national ID, but the ability for fraudsters to do evil is dependent on there being no effective and secure universal identification. I'm going to guarantee that the NSA tracking profiles on every US citizen don't need national ID cards to pick you out of a crowd. They could build a comprehensive identity database from CCTV and store cameras whenever you buy something to build a complete and hardened profile to identify you with. They have access to way more than enough material to start branding the "undesirables" and having them carted off to gas chambers within a week. We just suffer in the meantime under this false belief that ID cards are the make or break of liberty.
- zxcmx 9y agoI upvoted you and I think you made your point well, I just feel the opposite way to you. Thanks btw :) I would prefer shitty nonfunctioning systems which still allow me to use cash and buy a bowl of noodles to the alternative where I need to be more or less authorised to make that transaction. But thats just me.
- theandrewbailey 9y agoUS already has national IDs. They're called Social Security Numbers.
- snuxoll 9y agoCGPGrey did an excellent video on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus
- snarf21 9y agoExactly, some of this is semantics. To me, a skimmer duplicated card isn't identity theft. Taking my identifying information and opening new credit is. Again, this whole industry needs to change. We could cut massive amounts of the estimated $200B loss in the US with just simple things like mandatory chip+pin, 2FA or CCV for online purchases, your credit is always frozen and only unfrozen for a 24 hour period at your specific request (requiring MFA). It is so silly when I have to type in my 5 digit zip at the gas pump (something someone could easily find online or by asking for ID) even though my card has a chip.
- jamra 9y agoSome banks offer virtual credit card numbers for one time use. It works great online. There are phone payment methods like Apple Pay and whatever Google uses that protect your identity. The burden should be on the providers of these services to secure themselves.
- zxcmx 9y agoNone of this works for you as a person if your easily look up-able information can be used to apply for credit. In a high trust society you are extremely vulnerable to this stuff. Low trust societies do not have this problem in the same way. The major problem really is that high trust society credit etc are optimising for sign up rate. Any kind of serious personal authentication mechanism will seriously impact conversion rate, which is the giant dashboard they have on the wall. There are whole teams of people whose job it is to make sign ups and conversions better. The fraud team is much smaller and as long as it doesn't impact the top line numbers too much they will be ignored.
- kiriakasis 9y agook... i think the point is that it should be mandated by law to have chip+pin(+maybe contactless)+CCV with credit cards, and also two factor authentication for most online transaction. Whether the current business model does not provide these assurances is inconsequential: it can be imposed as a customer protection law. It is to be discussed whether the increase in the cost of the service would be worth it though.
- zxcmx 9y agoThis is a wonderful idea but it is not cognisant of risk or user experience. I am sort of surprised more HNers don't understand risk and the tradeoffs involved and seem to be taking an absolutist stance on this. Equifax is an unforgivable failure of infosec but the general ideas around the risk of it seem like ... Practically speaking, without significant landscape changes (and yeah equifax counts as one) it has generally been cheaper to trust people and write off the bad apples than to verify more. Or else there would be more verification! Thats because most applications for homes, high value insurance or financial products are not actual fraud, they are usually consumers having trouble with you shitty process despite your best efforts to optimise for usability. I don't know fully what the equifaxopocalypse means for americans though.
- kiriakasis 9y agoI read many of your comments on this post and still do not seem to get your point. You argue that there are reasons for the lack in verifications and then that this is desiderable from a societal point of view. To the question "should a CC provider cover the expenses on CC give to fraudolent impersonators?" what do you answer?
- Noughmad 9y ago> it has generally been cheaper to trust people and write off the bad apples than to verify more This is not the issue here. If a bank want to do this, go ahead, as long as they cover the losses. The problematic part is that if a bank gives a loan in my name to someone else, I get punished for it, not the bank.
- zxcmx 9y agoTell me which party to the transaction you are as you make this rational decision. Or explain that you don't understand the industry or any of the regulatory frameworks involved. Have you ever accepted a payment? EDIT: not sure if I misread you, probably responding to a comment in flight. Your initial position seemed to be different to what I read now. I get that "identity fraud" as an industry position is a shitty attempt at moving risk but that was not the comment I was reponding to. Sorry if that sucks.
- kwhitefoot 9y ago> a secure government authentication method, but that's not beyond implementation We have secure epost for communications between people and the state here in Norway already. The authorities keep pestering me to register to use it so that they no longer have to send me paper documents.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoIs it actually secure or is that just the marketing ploy of the government?
- kwhitefoot 9y agoI don't really know. I've never heard of any exploits but that could be because it might simply not be an attractive enough target.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- drewg123 9y agoUS credit card companies do not do a lot of ID verification when opening accounts. I applied for a new CC last year entirely on-line, and had the new card in my hands within a week. They never asked to verify my identity beyond my SSN / DOB / Address, which all seem likely to have been released in at least 3 breaches in the last few years. This is surprising to me, as I've been asked to show ID when opening a local bank account. To me this makes no sense: Why verify customers more stringently when they effectively loan you money than when you loan them money? I guess it may just have something to do with banking laws.. This is all just a long winded way to say that I think that credit card offers, by mail or web, are a problem. They cannot do any meaningful ID verification anymore, now that all info is essentially public. I think they need to partner with some agency that has a physical presence which can do verification of ID via government issued ID. Eg, a bank, merchant, etc, who can look at your driver license, passport, etc, and verify your identity. I suppose they are worried about adding too much friction.
- astura 9y agoBecause bank accounts have different (and stricter) anti-money laundering and KYC laws.
- drewg123 9y agoWhich, no offense to our government, is just stupid. I'm much more concerned about ID theft than I am about terrorism, which is the supposed motivation for the know your customer stuff.
- scott_s 9y agoI think those laws were originally designed for "normal" crime, as what-to-do-with-illict-money is a common problem for anything resembling organized crime.
- kiriakasis 9y agoIng. Direct ask for copy of your documents to be sent by mail
- lowbloodsugar 9y ago>then clearly they didn't do their verification properly. Indeed. And surely, when they then report you to a credit agency, then this is libel or slander. They have no reasonable basis to make the claim, and it results in severe hardship for you. As OP says, the idea of "Identity" is a fiction designed to make it the responsibility of the citizen to deal with the "theft". By definition, if it can be stolen, then it can't be considered an identity.