3 ms·
Many of these ideas seem aimed only at harming "Wall St", not at providing benefits to consumers. For example, 1. No one forces customers to deposit money in b
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Many of these ideas seem aimed only at harming "Wall St", not at providing benefits to consumers.
For example, 1. No one forces customers to deposit money in banks, they do it because a valuable service is provided (ATM's, direct deposit). How will using a check cashing place (thereby disrupting wall st) help me?
Or 4. If you don't want your money "skimmed" by high frequency folks (disclaimer: I'm one of them) and don't want to pay commissions, use ALO orders [1]. This has the problem that your order might never be filled. If I
want to own 100 shares of Tesla now (and I believe it is worth $1.00, assuming a bid/ask of $0.01), how does harming wall st help me?
Or 8. The author seems unaware that mutual funds are already being disrupted...by the ETF's (issued by Wall St) he suggests we buy. Maybe we should stick are money under a mattress?
To borrow a phrase from other discussions, "the goal isn't to kill facebook, it's to help our customers." This applies here - focus on the consumer, not on the competitor.
[1] http://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/ProductsServices/Trading/postonly_factsheet.pdf&pli=1 http://www.nasdaqtrader.com/content/ProductsServices/Trading...
http://www.nyse.com/equities/nysearcaequities/1157018931913.html http://www.nyse.com/equities/nysearcaequities/1157018931913....
- loganfrederick 16y agoThe idea is that harming "Wall St." will help consumers, but you're right that it's secondary to helping them first. Lots of problems Dixon listed revolve around fees, and my guess is that a lot of people feel ripped off by the financial industry because it makes tons of money while not seeming to provide equal value. Any disruption that lowers the costs of doing business helps both customers while achieving Dixon's goal of disrupting the establishment. This is true in many industries.
- _delirium 16y agoI think there's a good correlation, though. High profit margins are a big flashing red light that consumers could be getting something better or cheaper or both, since in competitive markets, high profit margins don't persist. So they're a decent way of identifying where disruptive opportunities lie: figure out why these high profit margins are persisting, and how your startup can move in on that territory.
- yummyfajitas 16y ago...in competitive markets, high profit margins don't persist A couple of the markets Dixon identified are not competitive, namely credit cards and mutual fund management [1]. But quite a few are highly competitive and don't have high profit margins: retail banks, market making (HFT) and research, for example. Prop trading is also highly competitive, but profits are high because the risk is high as well. Dixon explicitly advises individuals not to compete with the big players because they will probably lose. It's hard even for big players - remember AIG, Lehman and Bear? Thousands of hedge funds went under, so many that the big banks had to lay off most of their prime brokerage divisions. [1] Mutual funds benefit from an agency problem - your employer selects which funds you can put your retirement into. I'd love to buy low cost ETF's, but then I wouldn't get the tax advantage.
- jbooth 16y agoCompetitive doesn't necessarily mean productive. The stock market functioned perfectly well (well, you know what I mean) for 100 years before HFT came about. Now that it's here, does the stock market work better? No, it works worse, if anything. It's just another way for insiders to win by rigging the game. My problem with Wall St and seemingly Dixon's is that it's all about rigging things to your advantage rather than competing on quality. HFT doesn't create value, it just agglomerates wealth to those with servers in the right colos. Mutual funds and credit cards, as you say, are optimized towards leveraging an immovable market position to extract money from the rest of the economy. If someone on Wall St is creating value commensurate with their salary, I'm all about that. But it seems like the vast majority are extracting their salary from the rest of the country as an effective tax on investment rather than actually creating wealth.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhy do you believe the market works worse than in the past? I'm genuinely curious why you think this, because based on what I can see, the market is vastly more efficient today. In the past, you'd pay a market maker 1/8 or 1/4, and even then only in thickly traded securities. In thinly traded securities, your order might just go unfilled. The market makers were humans with a physical seat on the trading floor rather than a server in a colo and you'd pay your broker $100/trade (assuming you could get him on the phone). Now you pay a $0.01-0.02 spread, maybe $0.10 on thinly traded securities. You pay your broker $0-$10/trade and you can trade from your N1 or iphone. A colo server is also much cheaper than access to the physical trading floor. HFT provides value: liquidity and immediacy. If you don't believe that is worth $0.02, you can place ALO orders and you won't need to pay for it.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]