4 ms·
I wonder how many other apps on Apple's "guaranteed-safe" App Store have hidden behavior like this? Since I can't actually audit the app code that runs on my d
by jrockway 16y ago
I wonder how many other apps on Apple's "guaranteed-safe" App Store have hidden behavior like this? Since I can't actually audit the app code that runs on my device (like by compiling it myself), nor can I audit the OS, I guess I now have to assume that any application on my iPhone is compromised. (+)
Apple should include a warning on the box to that effect.
(+) I don't actually own an iPhone.
- chc 16y agoI feel pretty vindicated, because I've been saying all along that the App Store review process is pointless at best, because the things apps are usually rejected for are fairly petty and it has almost no way of picking up on anything but the dumbest malware.
- IgorPartola 16y agoI think that should be "the things that people make a huge fuss about are pretty petty." I think that the review process adds a certain value to the App Store. I know that if I download an app, (1) it will run and (2) it will do more or less what the description says. That is not to say that this is the one true way, but it adds value. I think a model that the web has followed is better: apps should be ranked based on some organic factors (e.g.: content of description + reviews) and the best apps can just float to the top. Security can be ensured via reviews/ratings + sandboxes access to phone's core functions.
- chc 16y agoI think you may have misunderstood the term "petty." Even the rejections people don't make a fuss about are fairly petty for the most part (dictionary definition: "of little importance; trivial"). They're mostly things like "You forgot this one guideline" or "You have a small bug in this part of the app."
- IgorPartola 16y agoSame as the Debian policy. That doesn't seem to be a big deal in that community. Are the guidelines for the the App Store? Does it seem okay to ship a product with known bugs? Admittedly, I've never gotten an app approved by Apple, but as an iPhone user I can appreciate these things.
- Goladus 16y agoWell, ignoring for the moment that there's always some controversy with regards to contributions to Debian and other Linux distributions, Debian doesn't have an app store. If there is software you can't get using apt-get out of the box, for example, if you want the real firefox and not iceweasel, you might need to add a repository to your config file. Or maybe just wget a url and install a .deb file manually. Or you can just download the source and compile it yourself. Can't do any of that on the iPhone. It's the app store or you figure out some way to beat Apple's security.
- IgorPartola 16y agoMy point with this is that while Apple is going about things the wrong way, they are in fact adding value. Simply removing the approval process and letting any app into the app store will be a bad thing.
- wallflower 16y agoApps are sandboxed. They can send and receive data over http/https at will. Location sharing is much more audited in iOS 4. Your calendar data and some address book data is not well protected. Your pictures are only accessible through the camera roll UI; apps can't slurp them.
- maxjg 16y agoYour contacts are pretty much completely unprotected as well. As an iPhone developer myself, I don't think it's unreasonable to have the device ask for permission to use this data (in a similar manner as location data access is approved).
- ajg1977 16y agoContacts (and in iOS 4, calendar data) are completely unprotected. Just create an instance of an AddressBook and go to town. Your pictures are only accessible through the camera roll UI... IF the developer is only using public APIs. Since we can assume that there are no public APIs that support tethering setup, we can also assume that it's still possible for them to be used in rogue apps and for developers to have access to private data.
- pieter 16y agoYou can make a perfectly fine SOCKS proxy without using any unpublished API's. It's just listening on one socket and then opening a new one based on the request.
- bombs 16y agoIt's possible to create a tethering app using public APIs. The APIs for HTTP/HTTPS connectivity and WiFi connectivity are public. Apple rejects apps that use private APIs.
- tomjen3 16y agoHow does Apple actually scan for private APIs? Couldn't you write the instructions necessary to make the private API call on the stack at runtime and then simply execute an assembly jump instruction?
- jsz0 16y agoApple has never guaranteed the App Store is safe. They've pushed the idea that the App Store is safer than alternatives though. The iPhone EULA covers this.
- tvon 16y agoWell, that's pretty much the a basic OSS argument that's been around since day 1, just applied to a specific device.