2 ms·
I'm not suggesting Google be the moral police: I'm suggesting Google take the necessary measures to ensure they are not operating a criminal enterprise. General
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I'm not suggesting Google be the moral police: I'm suggesting Google take the necessary measures to ensure they are not operating a criminal enterprise. Generally, doing business in illegal goods is considered a crime, and Google was well aware that they will profiting on illegal rehab ads. But right now, they're not legally responsible for that, so they had no reason to do what they should've done: Individually have humans vet the ads.
Most businesses have to take reasonable steps to ensure they're not aiding and abetting criminal activity. Pawn shops register stuff sold to them and who sells it, and they lose out if something they bought turns out to be stolen. Gun stores run background checks. Banks end up on the hook for fraudulent charges. Google just profits and has blanket immunity from prosecution. Google made millions of dollars (at least) off sending people suffering from drug addictions to scammers, and got to walk away with all the profit scot-free.
- moftz 9y agoIn this case what should ad networks like Google do to make sure they are running ads for legit businesses? In your gun store example, the seller is relying on the government to provide any information that would disqualify a sale. Rarely is a gun shop going to deny a sale despite government approval unless there is suspicion of a crime happening. If these scam rehab clinics can show Google they are properly licensed by the state they reside in, then what else should Google be doing? Google is not a medical license board. The states need to make sure that any sort of rehab or medical facility is legit and using best practices. These clinics rely on insurance money coming in so insurance companies would definitely be interested in making sure that the clinics they are paying out to are using effective treatments. I could see Google having a clause stating that if any business advertises themselves as any sort of medical or rehab facility, that they provide documentation from the state that proves such. This should be the same with doctors, lawyers, notaries, professional engineers, or anyone that advertises themselves as something that requires an approval from the government. Despite Google making a lot of money off of dubious advertisements, if Google can verify that a business is properly licensed to do what they advertise, then Google shouldn't be at fault for any fraud that is being committed. If someone shoots someone unlawfully and the gun was purchased legally, the gun shop doesn't get in trouble.
- jessaustin 9y ago"criminal enterprise" Sketchy rehab sucks, but is it always a criminal enterprise? The fact that Florida had to pass some new laws indicates that may not be the case in many states even now. (Even in Florida, it would be somewhat miraculous if they got the new laws precisely correct on the first try.) Even assuming an airtight law, where does the line get drawn? The gold-plated rehab that Hollywood stars use costs more than most insurance would pay. The rehab mentioned in TFA that keeps addicts high and prostitutes them was obviously a criminal enterprise even before the new laws. There is a lot of space in the middle, and outlawing very basic rehab might just mostly deprive addicts of that service. This is a difficult line to draw. One might imagine insurance companies or government regulators drawing it (even if perhaps they haven't yet...), but how could Google do so? My impression is that Google's corporate cultural DNA is somewhat reluctant to insert itself into this sort of transaction in this way, but some other giant internet companies would be eager to get all in the business of assigning users to rehab centers.