5 ms·
At $230 a click, Google has no incentive to stop selling scams, particularly with internet regulation being so weak. Safe harbor effectively gives them immunity
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
At $230 a click, Google has no incentive to stop selling scams, particularly with internet regulation being so weak. Safe harbor effectively gives them immunity to prosecution for profiting on the malicious content they host. All they have to say is "we're not responsible for content others post on our platforms".
Currently, The Verge has more power to regulate Google's behavior does than the US government, by bringing them to the court of public opinion. Which is why I have actually started to lean in favor of laws that strip away safe harbor protections like SESTA.
Internet companies don't need or deserve blanket immunity: They should be able to be taken to court when they misbehave.
- izacus 9y agoHere's an idea - let's punish the scum that creates those ads instead of demanding that Google plays the moral police for the whole world. You're literaly demading that Google (a private for-profit corporation) becomes a private censorship force instead of going after scum that creates those ads.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI'm not suggesting Google be the moral police: I'm suggesting Google take the necessary measures to ensure they are not operating a criminal enterprise. Generally, doing business in illegal goods is considered a crime, and Google was well aware that they will profiting on illegal rehab ads. But right now, they're not legally responsible for that, so they had no reason to do what they should've done: Individually have humans vet the ads. Most businesses have to take reasonable steps to ensure they're not aiding and abetting criminal activity. Pawn shops register stuff sold to them and who sells it, and they lose out if something they bought turns out to be stolen. Gun stores run background checks. Banks end up on the hook for fraudulent charges. Google just profits and has blanket immunity from prosecution. Google made millions of dollars (at least) off sending people suffering from drug addictions to scammers, and got to walk away with all the profit scot-free.
- moftz 9y agoIn this case what should ad networks like Google do to make sure they are running ads for legit businesses? In your gun store example, the seller is relying on the government to provide any information that would disqualify a sale. Rarely is a gun shop going to deny a sale despite government approval unless there is suspicion of a crime happening. If these scam rehab clinics can show Google they are properly licensed by the state they reside in, then what else should Google be doing? Google is not a medical license board. The states need to make sure that any sort of rehab or medical facility is legit and using best practices. These clinics rely on insurance money coming in so insurance companies would definitely be interested in making sure that the clinics they are paying out to are using effective treatments. I could see Google having a clause stating that if any business advertises themselves as any sort of medical or rehab facility, that they provide documentation from the state that proves such. This should be the same with doctors, lawyers, notaries, professional engineers, or anyone that advertises themselves as something that requires an approval from the government. Despite Google making a lot of money off of dubious advertisements, if Google can verify that a business is properly licensed to do what they advertise, then Google shouldn't be at fault for any fraud that is being committed. If someone shoots someone unlawfully and the gun was purchased legally, the gun shop doesn't get in trouble.
- jessaustin 9y ago"criminal enterprise" Sketchy rehab sucks, but is it always a criminal enterprise? The fact that Florida had to pass some new laws indicates that may not be the case in many states even now. (Even in Florida, it would be somewhat miraculous if they got the new laws precisely correct on the first try.) Even assuming an airtight law, where does the line get drawn? The gold-plated rehab that Hollywood stars use costs more than most insurance would pay. The rehab mentioned in TFA that keeps addicts high and prostitutes them was obviously a criminal enterprise even before the new laws. There is a lot of space in the middle, and outlawing very basic rehab might just mostly deprive addicts of that service. This is a difficult line to draw. One might imagine insurance companies or government regulators drawing it (even if perhaps they haven't yet...), but how could Google do so? My impression is that Google's corporate cultural DNA is somewhat reluctant to insert itself into this sort of transaction in this way, but some other giant internet companies would be eager to get all in the business of assigning users to rehab centers.
- reilly3000 9y agoScum comes along when there is room for ‘great margin’. That almost always comes when there is monopoly or deception. The subprime mortgage crisis happened when there was deception of investors about the quality of mortgage-backed securities. An effect of that was that companies that had no exposure to loan quality perversely had an incentive to originate large volumes of low quality loans. Mortgage brokers earn points on transactions, so a typical commission would be say 60 basis points on the loan amount. A $100k loan earns the broker $600. Typically this was paid to the broker and shared with any loan officer and processor employees(yes gatekeepers were paid commission!). Prime loans, home purchase loans, typically had similar yield spread premiums. Subprime loans were marketed so aggressively because their points ranged from 120-450, with the highest rates coming from Option ARMs. The same broker on the same $100k loan made $4500 vs $600. The rest is history. Margin. If there’s enough of it, there’s room for free beer, more of it, call centers and big ad campaigns, more of it, Vegas parties and dark money. It doesn’t matter where the margin comes from, the result is always the same. Source: I worked at a big mortgage lead gen company. Almost went to work for rehab lead site, then didn’t want to repeat prior mistakes.
- anonacct37 9y agoI don't want them to be moral police, but they should be held accountable when they are a silent partner in a shady business. It's just like pawn shops. After being robbed I realized that pawn shops entire business model is built on people who have stolen something and are happy to get any amount of money for what they had stolen. What pawnshops do isn't illegal, but if you spend more than 5m in a pawnshop, you realize they wouldn't exist if it weren't for drug addicts who needed their next fix. I witnessed someone walk in with a backpack full of random stuff. The people working the counter clearly knew her, they asked jokingly: "who's bag is that?" her response: "it's yours now". This is the secret of of facebook and google. This is what powers self driving cars and AI and massages at work and "moonshots". If the best defense of your actions is "it's not technically illegal", you might want to reassess your business model.
- bllguo 9y agoThe key is that Google's business model is not built on people that are behaving illegally. Google would obviously still exist if rehab scammers and other bad actors didn't. Given this, I find your call for Google to reassess its business model a weak one. People just want short-term, feel-good solutions. Google monitoring for shady rehab ads is exactly that. It's a kneejerk reaction that doesn't solve the real issues. These centers will still exist and inevitably ads will slip through the cracks. This is a failure of society and law enforcement that just happens to be most visible thru Google.
- anonacct37 9y ago> Google would obviously still exist if rehab scammers and other bad actors didn't. It's not obvious to me that google, in it's current insanely profitable form, would exist. As someone who has worked in ad-tech I think you might be underestimating how much of their money comes from rehab scammers, predatory lenders, get rich quick scams, weight loss scams, etc. Unfortunately I can't publish the numbers even if I still had them, but as an engineer looking through logs and building our tracking system I remember our biggest clients and who was paying us $400/lead. These companies are key business partners of google/facebook. They write the checks. I'm not advocating going after google as a short term solution to a failure in law enforcement. I'm advocating holding them responsible as a business partner to share in whatever consequences our law enforcement system deems appropriate.
- s73ver_ 9y agoNo. This is not censorship. This is Google choosing to not do business with the scum. And, given that Google is making money off this scum, they absolutely should be held accountable.
- whoopdedo 9y agoThis will not work while the cost of identifying and stopping bad ads is higher than that of creating new ads. The same reason robocalls and Nigerian email scams still exist. Google is in the best position to stop it, albeit with the spectre of a chilling effect. However even if Google completely cleaned house the bad ads would still exist because there are ad networks other than Google. I would suggesting holding website owners liable for the ads that appear on their sites. It makes it easier to identify who needs to be sued. The buck stops at the name in the URL bar.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThis is a poor solution because website owners are not responsible for selecting which ads appear on their sites: Google is. (Also, note that this story is primarily about Google Ads that appear in Google Search, so Google remains the issue either way.)
- eli 9y ago> Safe harbor effectively gives them immunity to prosecution for profiting on the malicious content they host I do not think this is true at all. See, for example, https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2011/aug/24/google-settles-us-drug-advertising-case https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2011/aug/24/google-se...
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt depends a bit on the jurisdiction and type of case. For instance, SESTA modifies Section 230 of the CDA, which chiefly grants companies like Google immunity from civil and criminal cases stemming from state and local law. Federal criminal law is explicitly excluded, so the DOJ, for example, could still go after them[1]. Intellectual property is also excluded from Section 230, but, that is covered elsewhere: The DMCA grants them significant immunity in copyright infringement cases. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communications_Decency_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230_of_the_Communicati...
- cromwellian 9y agoBe careful what you wish for. My guess is, the results of a flurry of suits would be what you're seeing on YouTube right now, demonetization of anything remotely controversial. You'll get squeaky clean ads from large dominant corporations, and the only content able to monetize them will be squeaky clean large content providers. Lost in the shuffle will be small content providers and small vendors who need to advertise. Then you'll be back on HN complaining about how Google is censoring everything and favoring big players, leading to greater concentration of media conglomeration, all the while ignoring that this is implicitly what you asked for by asking for costly regulation -- which doesn't hurt big firms as much as you think and primarily hurts smaller players. The internet's come along way from the freedom we imagined in the late 80s and 90s. In my college Cypherpunk days, I wrote one of the first anonymizing internet proxies to combat the Communications Decency Act (http://web.archive.org/web/20011122042440/http://www.clark.net:80/pub/rjc/decensedoc.html http://web.archive.org/web/20011122042440/http://www.clark.n...), because at the time, the internet was pretty much the only place in existence where the government did not have the ability to regulate people's behavior. Now we've arrived at a place where even so-called liberals, progressives, and civil libertarians, are calling for the government to censor indirectly, what can be published on the internet. And make no mistake, it is government censorship even if you are outsourcing that responsibility to private corporations via the civil courts, in much the same way that Extraordinary Rendition is still torture, even if the CIA outsources it to a third world dungeon. The FTC does not punish public radio and TV because shady diet scammers are selling snake oil. They don't shut down radio for Chiropractice (a pseudo-scientific medical scam), or for "financial advice" shows which sell people obviously bad investment advice on "market timing" when they'd be better off with an ETF. On any given day, I'd estimate about 50% of radio ads are scams on my way to work. How far do we take things to "protect" the public from scams and sex by censoring our media? How about harsh penalties for people operating the scams? Should you be allowed to Gmail because your spam filter let through an email scam and you got suckered by it?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI don't like your assertion that preventing criminal activity is censorship. Fraud isn't speech: It's a criminal act to sell one thing and provide another. I also disagree that better moderation practices will hurt small players. Especially since most of the concerning fields of business will be high value lines. And Google cannot reasonably say it is unprofitable to sell advertising worth $230 per ad click if they have to verify it's quality first. It would be reasonable, I think, to suggest that humans should vet all advertising in these extremely high profit margin fields. The primary issue here is one of perverse incentives. Google profits heavily off criminal activity, and so has strong incentive to not only permit it, but implement practices which encourage or enable it. Google is a business, and businesses make decisions on profit. I'm sure you can agree with that. I'd hope you'd also recognize that the times in which Google does what is best for the consumer is generally the times in which those actions are also the best for Google. Like any corporation, it acts in it's own best interest. I know I've agreed with some of your thoughts, like preferring optional SafeSearch-type filtering on YouTube over removing adult content, so my question is, how do we get Google Ads incentives aligned with consumers? How do we make it bad for your employer to sell high-priced ads that are criminal?