3 ms·
Probably yes. I've heard that some people have had success at negotiating down the scope of their IP assignments to "Anything directly related to the company i
by nostrademons 16y ago
Probably yes.
I've heard that some people have had success at negotiating down the scope of their IP assignments to "Anything directly related to the company is yours, anything not directly related is mine", but it comes down to negotiating leverage. Basically, you need to be a bigshot in your industry and they need to be a relatively small, desperate company for this to work. They have to want you more than you want them, because otherwise they know that everyone else will require equally restrictive IP agreements.
As for how people manage to work on side projects - usually, if they become companies, the employee has to negotiate an explicit agreement with their employer to retain ownership. For the Apple I, Woz initially believed that HP owned the rights to it, and then some middle-manager at HP signed it away. For Viaweb, I believe there was a panic at some point where some Yahoo pointed out that it was quite possible that Altavista owned the rights to their code (since RTM worked there one summer) and they needed to get some manager there to sign off on it. PG may be able to tell you more if he's reading this.
Another common strategy founders do is write the prototypes and perform market research while still employed, and then throw everything away and start fresh when they form the company. Usually the scope of IP only extends to code (& design docs & other written descriptions), because if it's not written down, you can't prove when they dreamed it up. This was the Netscape strategy: write Mosaic, quit and rewrite it as Netscape. They got sued for it anyway, but I think it was for trademark infringement and not copyright infringement.
- b3nman 16y agoThis is my own company. I feel like i should be able to have my own side projects later, but will investors get squeamish if they see I have a non-standard agreement?
- nostrademons 16y agoI dunno; I'd imagine that it depends on the investor. One of my previous employers had the California clause ("except for inventions developed entirely on their own time on their own machines" blah blah) even though they weren't a California company, perhaps because their law firm was more familiar with that. One thing they probably will get squeamish with is if the founders have different IP agreements than the employees. They'll probably also wonder how committed you are to the company if you're already thinking about side projects...