4 ms·
Q: Why does it need to be posted to HN every quarter and make top story? A: Why does it need to be posted to HN [by HN users] every quarter and make top story
by Groxx 16y ago
Q: Why does it need to be posted to HN every quarter and make top story?
A: Why does it need to be posted to HN [by HN users] every quarter and make top story [because HN users have voted it up]?
The community (which is why the site exists) hath spoken!
- derefr 16y agoNo. This conception of "the democracy makes the rules" is what turns sites into inane cat-picture/political-argument factories. Tiny democracies can work as closed systems, but when they're open to people entering/leaving them, every change will precipitate a change in membership to realign the community's interests with the change. This causes a positive feedback loop, where eventually, for example, nobody is left except Apple addicts. Sites have purposes (otherwise, there would only need to be one website on the Internet, that served everyone's needs equally.) Letting the community decide both what, and who, the community is to be composed of, leads inevitably to every community being composed of "everyone," and having a purpose of "general interest." I, for one, would rather have a place that just has "Hacker News."
- schammy 16y ago> I, for one, would rather have a place that just has "Hacker News." Amen, brother.
- Groxx 16y agoYou say this, yet the submitter has been here over 1000 days, and over 100 longer than you. Evidently at least some of the long-timers, from when this was a much more closed environment, do indeed see this as interesting news. So the question becomes: what's the definition of "hacker news", if not a user-submitted aggregator? And where do you define what is and what is not HN-worthy? It's apparently not age-related, nor precedence, nor community, and I don't know how you'd define what's hacker-related and what's not, barring strict, literal "hacks" (and then how about circuit bending to make music?).
- schammy 16y agoIt's just the fanboys voting it up. Nothing wrong with being a fanboy, I'm just saying. This news is of no interest to the general community here, except the people who love Apple more than themselves. And apparently, there are quite a few of these people here. I come here to read news about startups, not to indulge in Apple lovefests. If I wanted to do that, I'd be over at TechCrunch.
- pclark 16y agoPeople that blindly hate upon everything Apple is just as bad as people that blindly love Apple.
- schammy 16y agoI'm not hating on Apple. Re-read my posts and tell me one place where I said anything negative about Apple. I'm simply asking a question - why is this news relevant to this community and why do we have to have a top-story post on it every quarter? What use is that to anyone here? And for this simple question, I have lost almost 40 points of karma in the last hour. Thanks everyone. What a great community.
- Groxx 16y ago>Thanks everyone. What a great community. We do what we can to discourage repetitive whining. I'd say it works pretty well, because the site as a whole is remarkably free from it.
- sorbus 16y agoIt's just the fanboys; try to ignore them. They downvote anyone who expresses an opinion which they disagree with, or which they think is anti-apple. When the more sane users get to these comments, you'll regain at least a bit of your karma, probably.
- dman 16y agoI do agree that going against the grain isnt very well rewarded on hn (or for most online communities for that matter). But you do have my respect for expanding the discussion space and asking what I think is a legitimate question.