5 ms·
"Indeed if TfL have any kind of ulterior motive for their actions, it is simply that they dislike the impact Uber are having on congestion within the capital"
by rahimnathwani 9y ago
"Indeed if TfL have any kind of ulterior motive for their actions, it is simply that they dislike the impact Uber are having on congestion within the capital"
As compared with official London taxis (aka 'black cabs'), cars operated by Uber:
1) After dropping off a passenger, drive to their next pickup point (vs. black cabs which drive around for an average of 25 mins waiting to be hailed).
2) Pay the London congestion charge (vs. black cabs which are exempt despite the fact that they're generally on the road for about 10+ hours per day than the average car, and spend a far greater proportion of that total time within the congestion charging zone).
- mbrookes 9y ago3) Are typically petrol (gas) rather than diesel, and are often hybrids (less pollution). Edit: Not significantly smaller, as pointed out below 4) Are typically more compact than a black cab - take up less road space So no, it's not about congestion in that sense. What the author appears to be suggesting is that there are more cars on the road plying for the same trade, and the more journey miles taken in an Uber, the more idle time a black cab will spend waiting to be hailed - either congestion on the road, or congestion in the taxi ranks. However, if that were the true ulterior motive, that could be applied to any car service that competes with black cabs, not just Uber.
- rahimnathwani 9y ago5) Don't drive in bus lanes (black cabs can and do drive in most bus lanes; other cars cannot, regardless of number of passengers).
- rootlocus 9y agoHow is this an argument against black cabs? Bus lanes in my city are usually empty. Allowing cars on bus lanes would actually lower congestion.
- vertex-four 9y agoFor the record, London is a city where for some major routes, there's buses every 2-3 minutes. They're a major part of the public transport infrastructure in London. Bus lanes in much of the city centre are never empty. The simple answer, then, is that black cab drivers are tested on successfully fitting in with the flow on bus lanes so that they don't slow down buses, and minicab drivers are not.
- rootlocus 9y agoAlso for the record, here's a quote from a different post by the same parent: > 3) I used to drive to and from work every day. Part of the journey took me along the A4/M4 towards Heathrow. There was a traffic jam every day, going home from work (towards Central London). This busy road had a bus lane. I don't recall ever seeing a bus going past me in that lane, but plenty of black cabs did. I don't see why a black cab should get to skip past the rest of us waiting 20 mins in traffic.
- vertex-four 9y agoPerhaps there are some bus lanes in London that are very very underused and should be turned into regular lanes. Perhaps the people in charge of roads have discovered that if they were to remove that bus lane, the result would be congestion further into the city in a location less able to handle it than a motorway. Perhaps, for operational reasons, the buses absolutely need to be able to bypass traffic on the motorway. As for black cabs, perhaps it would be a complete hassle to implement a "no black cabs" rule for that one road just to avoid upsetting people who chose to drive into London. There's all sorts of potential reasons for that bus lane existing - and there's a very good chance that if someone were to file a FOI request with TfL, they have a report on the potential results of removing that bus lane.
- Symbiote 9y ago> Perhaps the people in charge of roads have discovered that if they were to remove that bus lane, the result would be congestion further into the city in a location less able to handle it than a motorway. It's a well-known controversial bus lane, which became a political issue. Anyone complaining about it loses my respect on HN, as they didn't look at the traffic engineering problem, just the Daily Mail hate. The motorway is 3 lanes until the final stretch into London, which has two lanes. The width reduction isn't at a junction, so the extra lane didn't help traffic flow -- it just caused congestion and collisions by making drivers merge. The lane was ended at the preceding junction's slip road, and a bus lane continued for the spare length. This improved journey time for buses (a minority of vehicles, but a decent proportion of people), and also improved journey times for cars! But, the sight of the bus lane annoyed the Tories, so they got rid of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M4_bus_lane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M4_bus_lane https://waronthemotorist.wordpress.com/2010/11/22/the-m4-bus-lane/ https://waronthemotorist.wordpress.com/2010/11/22/the-m4-bus... is where I first heard about it (I lived in London at the time, but didn't have a car.)
- cannam 9y ago> 4) Are typically more compact than a black cab - take up less road space I thought "that can't be right, black cabs aren't all that big". And a quick search suggests that a Prius and a TX4 black cab are pretty much the same length - 454cm (Prius) vs 458cm (cab). The black cab is 18cm wider, which may make a difference, although length seems the more significant dimension here. And black cabs are much taller of course.
- mbrookes 9y agoHuh, seems perception is not always reality. Thanks for fact checking! 18cm could make a difference navigating some of our narrower streets, but my mental image was that there was a more significant difference than there actually is. I've edited my original comment.
- rootlocus 9y ago> vs. black cabs which drive around for an average of 25 mins waiting to be hailed I'm not from London, but where I'm from, cab drivers don't "drive around" until the next ride. That's a terrible waste of gas. We have special reserved parking for them, usually close to places of interest (next to bus stations, malls, etc.). This is one of the reasons there is a limited number of licenses available per city. Uber drivers can't use these parking slots. How about the fact that black cabs wait to be hailed longer period of times because people choose Uber drives, thus adding more cars on the road instead of using the ones that are already there?
- lugg 9y ago> How about the fact that black cabs wait to be hailed longer period of times because people choose Uber drives, thus adding more cars on the road instead of using the ones that are already there? You can't be serious.. - Price - Accessibility - Customer service To name a couple.
- rootlocus 9y agoI was replying to an argument made about how black cabs are worse for congestions than uber cars.
- DanBC 9y agoWait, are you trying to say Uber are more accessible than black cabs? They and their drivers keep getting sued for refusing to take guide dogs or wheelchairs, or trying to charge extra for doing so.
- rahimnathwani 9y ago'I'm not from London, but where I'm from, cab drivers don't "drive around" until the next ride.' Then perhaps my points don't apply to wherever that place is. But I'm talking about London, and never claimed to be stating universal truths :)
- rootlocus 9y ago
- Nursie 9y agoThe implication is that the subsidised fares Uber offers are leading more people to use individual road transport. Why do people frame this as "Uber vs Black Cabs"? That completely misses out on the wider context of transport in London as a whole.
- rahimnathwani 9y ago> Why do people frame this as "Uber vs Black Cabs" I can't speak for others, but my tuppence as someone born in London, and who lived there for >30 years: 1) Black cabs are really expensive. So much so that I can count on one hand the number of times I've paid for one out of my own pocket. 2) Black cabs, despite the terms of their licence, are known to refuse to pick you up if they're going the other way, or refuse a fare if you're going to South London (where I was born). 3) I used to drive to and from work every day. Part of the journey took me along the A4/M4 towards Heathrow. There was a traffic jam every day, going home from work (towards Central London). This busy road had a bus lane. I don't recall ever seeing a bus going past me in that lane, but plenty of black cabs did. I don't see why a black cab should get to skip past the rest of us waiting 20 mins in traffic. 4) There are many taxi ranks where taxis wait for fares. For example, near Kings Cross station. 100% of the drivers leave their diesel engines running whilst they're waiting, right next to the pavement where people are walking. I don't like this unnecessary local pollution as I'm walking by. 5) Congestion charge (see my original comment). Overall, my point is this: Uber and minicab firms work within the same road usage framework as other car owners. Black cabs are somehow exempt from this (which is unfair to begin with) when, given the time they spend on the road waiting to find a passenger, they cause much more congestion and pollution per passenger-mile than other cars.
- detaro 9y ago1) and 2) make it sound like Uber potentially going away would have more influence on other Minicabs and not so much on Black Cabs?
- Nursie 9y agoRight, so you don't like Black Cabs. That doesn't answer my question. The choice isn't Uber or Black Cabs. It's London with Uber or London without Uber. How are cabs even relevant at all to the point your original post brings up? "Indeed if TfL have any kind of ulterior motive for their actions, it is simply that they dislike the impact Uber are having on congestion within the capital" I.E. Uber is adding a mass of cars to the street and worsening congestion, likely by offering cheaper fares and tempting people off busses and the tube. Surely Black Cabs aren't relevant to that point?
- vertex-four 9y agoThe goal of the congestion charge is not to make money off cars in London - it's an attempt to reduce the number of cars in London. The number of cabs is limited largely by the complexity of The Knowledge, while the number of minicabs is rather less limited, so in conspiracy theory land, TfL have motive to ban minicab operators wherever possible. In any case, it's very unlikely that this is an ulterior motive - there's no reason why the problems aren't exactly what was listed, i.e. mostly administrative failures on Uber's part where other minicab companies are more cooperative with the license requirements.
- tomp 9y ago> it's an attempt to reduce the number of cars in London Not sure if that's true. I think it's mainly to reduce the polution in central London. Otherwise, electric/hybrid cars wouldn't be exempt but charged the same amount!
- vertex-four 9y agoAh, true. I do think we'll see a congestion charge on electric cars as they become more popular, though - London plain and simple doesn't have enough space for personal road traffic. Edit: Hmm. London's own stuff claims that it was originally largely intended to reduce use of personal vehicles, and then in 2008 the Mayor implemented the current system of charging based on pollution. Again, I suspect it'll go back to charging for electric vehicles once people actually own electric vehicles.
- misnome 9y agoI'm not sure the two aims are in conflict. I'm pretty sure that consumer electric cars were pretty much nonexistent when the congestion charge was first implemented.
- Nursie 9y ago>> I think it's mainly to reduce the polution in central London. I lived in London when it was launched, it was also to do with making the city centre flow again, so that those who actually needed to be there could travel in a reasonable amount of time.
- reallydoubtful 9y agoYour second part is not true. As the blog post makes clear, Uber cars drive under the license of a minicab firm (as personal hire vehicles), and are therefore exempt from the congestion charge. Given your first point, could you please share the like-for-like data on uber vs. black cab time spent waiting to be hailed/booked? That sounds very interesting.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- monkeyprojects 9y ago2 isn't true private hire cars are equally exempt see https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/congestion-charge/discounts-and-exemptions https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/congestion-charge/discounts...
- rahimnathwani 9y agoI stand corrected. Sadly it's too late for me to edit my original comment.
- lozenge 9y agoBlack cabs are limited in number due to the difficulty of the Knowledge test. Ubers aren't limited in number and Uber makes no effort to discourage excess drivers from logging on. (If it reduces the average wait by 10 seconds, it's worth it in their eyes, as it costs them nothing. The congestion cost is externalised.) Uber also sends push notifications to drivers to go to specific areas to prevent surge pricing.