3 ms·
The problem is not going to be really solved until we get rid of the idea that a corporation can own land. The big agribusinesses don't value the land as much
by kwhitefoot 9y ago
The problem is not going to be really solved until we get rid of the idea that a corporation can own land. The big agribusinesses don't value the land as much as society needs them too so of course they don't look after it.
Land is a common resource and no one business should have unfettered control of it.
- bluGill 9y agoThat is false. Big business cares about land more than the small farmers It is the big farmers that care the most for the land. They are big enough that they have collected the data and seen that investments in the land pay off. When you have one field it is really hard to test for yourself how different practices pay off. The university will tell you "go no till, after 7 years your yields will be bigger than if you till the land every year", but small farmers generally think "yeah right, it works for your soils over there, but here we have different soils and so that won't work". By contrast the large farmers have enough fields that they are willing to try every new practice in a couple places to see if it really works for them. The largest farms are now able to scientifically show that they are building soil every year. Second, in Iowa corporations are banned form owning farms. There are exceptions for seed companies and equipment manufactures, but those are specific loopholes with limits to what can be done. I work for John Deere (but of course do not speak for them), and we have to be very careful that the places where we test our prototypes does not count as farms. (generally the crop is destroyed before harvest - I don't know how the harvester division does their testing though)
- kwhitefoot 9y agoI was not contrasting big and small farmers. I was contrasting big business behaviour with what society needs.
- bluGill 9y agoTrue, but big business behavior is often closer aligned with what society needs than small farmers.
- hamilyon2 9y agoWe tried that with kolkhoz system in USSR. The results were mixed. It occures to me that responsible, competent and forward-looking management of some resource can happen when that resource is privately owned.