2 ms·
>You're thinking about GMail TFA is about GMail. >there is only one legally defensible position as of today: full control of the legal entities handling the d
by closeparen 9y ago
>You're thinking about GMail
TFA is about GMail.
>there is only one legally defensible position as of today: full control of the legal entities handling the data
Absolutely! The GDPR does this, and it's perfectly coherent, in that it applies to all EU citizens' data, regardless of where the data is stored or processed.
What's incoherent is the (former) US policy that data held by American companies is immune to search if and only if it's located outside the US.
>Data has a location until it is copied multiple places
Data are copied hundreds to thousands of times as they transit any network. Further, if data at rest are only stored in one place, the company storing it is dangerously irresponsible. HIPAA actually mandates backup and disaster recovery capabilities. The illegal thing would be having too few copies, or an architecture with a single point of failure.
>The legislation is looking at something like the entirety Irish health services and handling sensitive individual research data
Surely something this sensitive should not rely on the "one weird trick" that US companies are (sometimes? maybe?) not required to comply with court orders for data that they claim lives on EU soil.