4 ms·
On my list of things to do today is build an image upload page for user profile images. I've been looking at using imagemagick. Maybe it's just me, but I have
by pedalpete 16y ago
On my list of things to do today is build an image upload page for user profile images. I've been looking at using imagemagick.
Maybe it's just me, but I have a bit of a NDH attitude towards this kind of service, and particularly at the pricing you are offering.
I'm not saying you won't be successful, that's just my two cents.
I suspect it is going to take me a few hours to figure out the imagemajick stuff. These seem to be quite a few tutorials on how to use it with Rails, so we'll see.
You aren't offering storage, and I actually think that is a good thing, as I wouldn't trust something like user images to a 3rd party start-up.
I guess I'm really wondering who your target market is.
I don't think (but I could be wrong) that the code to handle this sort of file-upload stuff is weeks worth of work. So if I can get it done in two hours, lets say that costs a company $100, and that is code we own, run on our servers, and the only further cost is storage.
If the target market is non-programmers, are you offering enough features to make managing photos and video easy enough for them?
I can encode videos on lots of sites for free, and get them served without paying any storage or bandwidth fees.
So if we just focus on photos, and the heavy lifting you are doing is the resizing and thumbnails, is that something that a newby would want to do? Or is it something that is so complicated that a programmer wants to avoid doing it?
I think what you are providing is some very basic tools, which is good because it is easy to understand, but I just don't know if the tools you are providing are compelling enough.
I guess I'll go code up what I need for my service, and if it isn't done by this afternoon, maybe you'll have convinced me that I need your service.
But I think that may be a challenge you're facing. Do most programmers think they can do this on their own?
- felixge 16y agoI agree with you, image resizing is simple enough that an average programmer can get it done. The reason we are offering it, is because it fits very naturally with our architecture, and people who handle video through us will probably also like us to handle their images. We do a few tricky things so. HTML5 multi uploading is one of them. We actually start resizing images as they come in, that means by the time you are done uploading 100 images, we are done resizing them. Another thing is upload progress without flash, that will usually require a custom-compiled web server of some sort. And there is meta data extraction and uploading to S3. If you just need a fraction of all of that, sure - we have little to offer. But we'll try even harder to make people regret their decision to "build it themselves" in the future : ). Let me know how far you get this afternoon! Edit: Our pricing will go down substantially. We basically decided to launch with the highest price we may get away with in order to go down with pricing over time instead of up.
- apsurd 16y agoBe sure to check out: http://github.com/thoughtbot/paperclip http://github.com/thoughtbot/paperclip (this also has an amazon s3 integration api) I share the same sentiment in that I know I could code out a solution in an afternoon and avoid spending 50 bucks a month for the rest of eternity. But I also do understand what OP is pitching. Services like these make prototyping that much faster, so I see it as a win for the agile development community. If the prices come down to "scrappy developer" levels, then much more people here on HN will certainly get it. But hey, your first job is to make money so what the hell do i know?