50 ms·
Is Tribalism a Natural Malfunction? What computers teach us about getting along
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tpallarino 9y agoWow. So if I'm understanding the article correctly, it says that tribalism occurs both naturally and in simulations. However, even though this is the case, we should despise tribalism for some reason that is frankly not exactly clear. does the depth of cultural self-loathing know no bound?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gt_ 9y ago>So if I'm understanding the article correctly, it says that tribalism occurs both naturally and in simulations. My take was that the article does not quite make these claims, but uses the simulations to model implications of them. >we should despise tribalism for some reason that is frankly not exactly clear We should move beyond tribalism because of it's inherence of prejudice.
- duckingtest 9y agoWhat these simulations show is that tribalism is a winning strategy. Which means not following it leads to death. >We should move beyond tribalism because of it's inherence of prejudice. Considering an inherent property of a winning strategy evil means your code is non-optimal and is inevitably going to disappear.
- gt_ 9y agoIt is a 'winning strategy' only for the winners. We can just as well call it a 'losing strategy'. As the players become more intelligent, they are able to cooperate better and everyone wins, meaning cooperation is even 'more winning'. That is, unless your intentions here are something like eugenics.
- duckingtest 9y agoIt's only possible for everyone to win if basic resources are infinite. Tribalism is the only pareto optimal strategy for finite resources, especially land on Earth.
- PeterisP 9y agoIt does seem that the article makes these claims - it describes a particular experiment where they unexpectedly discovered that tribalism emerged as the dominant (most successful) strategy in a competitive game they simulated.
- crispinb 9y ago> does the depth of cultural self-loathing know no bound I'm puzzled by this (possibly rhetorical?) question. Which culture is supposed to be loathing itself here?
- raverbashing 9y agoSomething that would be called "western/christian/european" civilization
- crispinb 9y agoHardly that I would think. The anti-tribal direction of modern world history originated in the Enlightenment, which, although catalysed by contacts with Muslim, Indian and Chinese civilisations, was nothing if not profoundly 'Western'.
- vikiomega9 9y agoHow is "western/christian/european" different from "western"? EDIT: the current framework of international order has roots in Westphalian notions of nation states, which is indeed christian and european.
- jacobolus 9y agoOne big point of “Western civilization” (religious mores about cousin marriage and inheritance; the classical liberal / republican tradition with religious toleration and representative government; science; European legal traditions with an independent judiciary; economic liberalism; down through to the Geneva Conventions; the UN and similar institutions; the Universal Declaration of Human Rights; universal education; universal suffrage; etc.) is rejecting tribalism in favor of the rule of law and more just and egalitarian social relations and decisionmaking processes.
- raverbashing 9y ago> religious mores about cousin marriage and inheritance (just because I didn't know that word) Mores: "The accepted traditional customs and usages of a particular social group." > is rejecting tribalism in favor of the rule of law Agreed. You just have to convince the other "tribes" to do that as well. And the more people are forced to accept other people from a more distant (not geographical distance) culture, the stronger the backlash is > more egalitarian social relations and decisionmaking processes How many forced marriages, FGMs and honour killings are happening now under the auspice of western secular governments/societies?
- jameslk 9y agoSex is a natural desire, but it's probably a good thing we have laws against those who force their way onto others whenever they're horny. Just because it's natural doesn't necessarily mean it's best.
- micheljones 9y agoYou are positing a false dichotomy here. Equivalent conclusion would be that 'sex is a natural malfunction and needs to be removed'.
- jamesrcole 9y agoTribalism tends to mean an "us vs them" attitude with emotive, knee-jerk dislike and demonising of "them", plus a disdain for constructive criticism of "us". I think history provides plenty of evidence of this and of how toxic it is.
- golemotron 9y agoThe irony is that the people who complain loudest about tribalism (nationalism, xenophobia) in contemporary political culture display exactly those attitudes toward people they disagree with. Anyone who thinks tribalism can be eliminated lacks self awareness or a least a mirror.
- jamesrcole 9y agoThat's definitely an issue. Regarding your second point, it's not a matter of the level of tribalism staying the same vs completely eliminating it. I think the overall levels have been reduced over the centuries, and there are people out there that are pretty non-tribalistic in outlook.
- benfle 9y agoOther things that occur both naturally and in simulations: revenge, jealousy, violence, territoriality, oligarchy, thumb sucking...
- Pica_soO 9y agoNatural Malfunction. Has humanity finally grown up so much, we can talk about the bugs the process called evolution produces? Can we actually talk about loop-deformations, and the danger that self-optimizing systems optimize try to optimize the social environment to the configuration that allows for a maximum self-reproduction performance? Will there be a open discussion on how only a constant economic bribe via surplus prevents civilization from sliding back into cyclic behavior? Or will it be just findings, a cultural look up on academic behavior from the resulting emotions and then dismissal of ones own findings as something of the past to overcome by praying and wishing/ strict social controls? Even though strict social controllism may also be a strategy that evolved as part of the loop? Who watches for bugs in the bug report mechanism? Who patches our social meta-organims against the found bugs? Who sets up laws to punnish exploits? One needs to stop having any influences of feeling towards humanitys bugs whatsoever. Feelings do not solve problems- at best they allow to avoid operations that crash the "cultural & biological software"- but the error persists. Just avoiding tribalism means, that it will rear its face, whenever there is stress on the system and it will do damage then, because by nature of not-understanding it will be uncontrollable. And why not use it for good? If tribalism is used to proof holes in the theorys of the neigbouring academia clans science - with the quasi-religious fervor of soccer fans, where is that not a positive, as long as a idea is not simply dismissed because of otherness? Imagine if you where allowed to wear shawls with dots for non-repeatable experiments in the colors of a "enemy" university?
- raverbashing 9y agoOh you can talk about it a lot, but do you fix it "Gattaca style" (troublesome) > Can we actually talk about loop-deformations, and the danger that self-optimizing systems optimize try to optimize the social environment to the configuration that allows for a maximum self-reproduction performance? That's what worked for millions of years. It's been tens of thousands of years since agriculture took over and while I don't subscribe to the Paleo ideas, our bodies evolved for lifespans long enough to reproduce, and for a low ratio of (calories obtained)/(calories spend obtaining food)
- tpallarino 9y agoAre Feelings a Natural Malfunction?
- jameslk 9y agoI'd like to know how much culture affects cooperation/trust in society vs other factors, such as genetics. I have a hypothesis that culture is much like a protocol. When all members of society speak the same protocol around each other, there is cooperation. The opposite is like your tragedy of the commons effect. This isn't to say that multi-culturalism would be bad if this hypothesis were true, only that all members of the society may need to at least understand a common culture to have cooperation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 9y agoIn the history of mankind (one of) the usual ways of having your tribe exterminated was meeting another tribe. Idealist ideas of the whole humanity singing kumbaya in a circule by the fireplace are naive at best. Doesn't mean "our tribe" (which exists in a lots of levels, it could be a sports team, it could be a national identity, or something more vague) needs to be hostile to others (or shoot first)
- kiliantics 9y agoAt the same time, many tribes benefitted from exchange and alliances. Tribalism does not necessarily imply brutal conflict.
- Nomentatus 9y agoTrue. There is at least one apparent exception, Australia, during hunter gatherer times. But everywhere else... Exchange and alliance also happened; often in aid of success in brutal conflicts.
- duckingtest 9y agoAllowing for coordinated protocol changes, the optimal length of pre-cooperative identification code should depend on the probability of error (defector). Which after a long enough time of winning (ie. close to zero defectors) would lead to jumping into cooperation immediately. Which would make defense against defectors impossible and lead to a total collapse as they exploit the hapless cooperators. Interesting parallels.
- pingou 9y agoInteresting. It seems like what they tested here was not that each agent should get as much points as possible like in a usual prisoner dilemma, but just that they should have more than the opponent (and thus get selected for reproduction). Not sure about the explanation in the article "This domination would last until enough errors accumulated in the code handed down between generations for dominant machines to stop recognizing each other.", shouldn't be the agents that stop recognizing the code forced out? I guess it depends on implementation details, if every agent can fight several opponents before being or not reproduced.
- arjie 9y agoI wonder if it also has an efficiency metric: a shorter agreeable program is better than a longer agreeable program. Then, over time, you start failing to detect bad programs after long periods of peace.
- zby 9y agoOK - by where is the code? This looks like something that would be great to tweak the parameters and code and experiment on your own. There was a similar work by Axelrode, it goes back to the 80s - but it also has some results that stunningly resonate with human moral strategies. And here is some Python code: https://github.com/Axelrod-Python/Axelrod https://github.com/Axelrod-Python/Axelrod
- notthemessiah 9y agoThe author is as quick to describe it as a "natural malfunction" as he is to his findings of his toy models to large complex societies. Can his analogy be applied on a different order of organization? Cells have very limited means of communicating with each other like this model, and in multi-cellular organism, they have a tendency to cooperate with things that share their code. Could this be said to be a malfunction?
- raverbashing 9y agoI disagree with the term malfunction as well, it's more of an heuristic for dealing with lack of perfect information about others
- golemotron 9y agoTribalism is seen all across nature. It is an important mechanism for adaptability and humanity wouldn't have made it as far as it has without it. The article equates it with its worst manifestations (war and genocide), but fails to appreciate its ecological importance. A world with only one large society is fragile and subject to large catastrophic failure. This is just like the issue of monoculture in software security. If there are many societies (tribes) there are more chances for survival. There are also more chances for independent discoveries of better ways of living that would otherwise be lost to groupthink. Tribalism is a diversified portfolio. It's not a bug, it's a feature. Our challenge is not to get rid of tribalism but rather how to get the best parts of it without the worst.
- gt_ 9y agoI agree with your conclusive point. On the others, I'm not sure we need to worry about losing tribalism any time soon so I hope you're not losing sleep over it.
- golemotron 9y agoI'm not. I'm just stunned by the ignorance of people who aim for that goal.
- gt_ 9y agoOf course, those people are all the while often reiterating it.
- jswizzy 9y agoAnyone who has watched a nature documentary knows that tribalism is essential for an organism longterm survival. Humans are just imaginative enough to want to transcend nature and reality. To quote Cormac McCarthy, "There's no such thing as life without bloodshed. I think the notion that the species can be improved in some way, that everyone could live in harmony, is a really dangerous idea. Those who are afflicted with this notion are the first ones to give up their souls, their freedom. Your desire that it be that way will enslave you and make your life vacuous."
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xtiansimon 9y agoTribalism in the fictional AMC show The Walking Dead is a survival response. Haha. Love that show. Cancer is largely understood as a failure of cell death mechanism--a negative mutation within the organism. Whereas the flu virus is rationally seen as part of the environment. It's effect in the body can be disastrous, but it also exercises our immune system. I think the conclusion is a grab bag of metaphors, and a poor conclusion to an interesting discussion of model and simulation.