4 ms·
> I guess, we as a species tend to have anger problem, no matter which societal form we live in. I'm not so sure about that. I think it has a lot to do with ho
by Razengan 9y ago
> I guess, we as a species tend to have anger problem, no matter which societal form we live in.
I'm not so sure about that. I think it has a lot to do with how we are raised and what we are taught when we come into this world, and it can be changed.
Recently I read some very nice fiction called the Green Sky Trilogy [0] (that has given rise to a video game which was far ahead of its time [1]), which depicts a pacifist society where there is a taboo on "unjoyful" behavior and activities, like anger and violence, but not on inherently "joyful" activities like sexual relations.
It really raised something I have always found very odd about our own world.
Why does almost every cultural on Earth, even relatively secular ones, repress activities that bring pleasure and life, but promote violence and death?
It's just bizarre.
Consider the infamous censorship of a TV show where they showed plenty of gore but not naked corpses, so they covered their buttocks with even more blood. [2]
Like we are supposed to be OK with that, but not nudity.
You have people beating each other up and show weapons and guns in children's cartoons, but shy away from showing anyone kissing someone.
So if we can condition ourselves to accept violence and strife – the causing of pain and death – things that are downright contrary to our existence, then we can condition ourselves to reject them as well.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Sky_Trilogy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Sky_Trilogy
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Below_the_Root_(video_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Below_the_Root_(video_game)
[2] https://www.google.com/search?q=Hannibal+censorship https://www.google.com/search?q=Hannibal+censorship
- scythe 9y agoI don't find such predictions at all utopian, and I'm surprised this thread of argument has persisted in culture so long. Sex is associated with pain and suffering, and that's why taboos exist. Whether it's unwanted children, unwanted contact, diseases, or unfulfillable desires, there's plenty of downside to sexual behavior. Violence is easier to understand correctly than sex: violence is always bad unless it's necessary, while the conditions which make sex good or bad are more complicated, and thus, less comprehensible to children. Every four-year-old knows you shouldn't actually drop anvils on people. Inappropriateness is an ingredient of slapstick comedy which is (partially) why characters in children's shows do bad things to each other. Note that Pepe le Pew nonetheless appears in children's shows; his attempts at romance are also obviously wrong and thus funny. On the other hand I do notice a positive correlation between people thinking the solutions to social problems are easy and people becoming angry about politics. This makes sense because it's natural to feel aggrieved when someone fails to solve an easy problem. But in reality the solutions to social problems are not so easy.
- Razengan 9y agoI edited the post a little to clarify the point I was trying to go for: If culture and upbringing can condition us to reject and feel awkward about our most basic instincts, then culture and upbringing can make us reject violence or causing grief to each other as well. By the way, the books I mentioned weren't "utopian predictions", in fact they have a dark side to them. For example, in that world even children are encouraged to take calming narcotics when they feel upset or agitated, which stifles them in different ways. Highly recommended reading in any case.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 9y ago> Why does almost every cultural on Earth, even relatively secular ones, repress activities that bring pleasure and life, but promote violence and death? In a pre-modern society, reproduction has to be controlled sociologically because it can’t be controlled technologically. And violence is how you do everything from get your food tonprotecting yourself from people trying to take your resources.
- Razengan 9y agoAh yes, the need for contraception for a free-loving culture is admitted in the Green Sky books as well. Technology also conveninetly obviates the need for violence to get food, even meat.
- louithethrid 9y agoEh, we where pretty long hunters and toughening up to kill that mammoth was pretty much part of all cultures who ate. The whole control on sexuality is a pure human thing- we are the only species who hides when in heat the stimulus to the opposit sex. My personal conclusion was, that this allowed for more energy to be diverted to other "culture" practices - such as building houses and the likes..
- PeterisP 9y agoIt's interesting that you're saying "almost every culture on Earth" when talking about a phenomenon that is quite USA-specific - e.g. most European cultures have no problems with nudity (either in TV or real world) but find the USA violence unacceptable e.g. censoring certain excesses of gore in videogames but leaving in all kinds of sexuality that's unwelcome in USA mass media. Most of the world is not how you describe, it seems that you're talking about local problems mostly particular to (among some other places) USA.