3 ms·
It's worth remembering that in the late 1990s, as Microsoft was facing its own security crisis and everybody hated the Wintel monopoly and how bloated Windows h
by nostrademons 9y ago
It's worth remembering that in the late 1990s, as Microsoft was facing its own security crisis and everybody hated the Wintel monopoly and how bloated Windows had become, several people put out calls for new systems to replace Windows. This was the era of Java applets, of Linux on the desktop, and of cross-platform widget libraries like Qt and WxWidgets.
What we actually got instead was the Web.
And the reason we got the web was because it was never conceived to be an application platform, and Microsoft crushed the only company who was calling it as such (Netscape) and declared victory, and then were caught completely unaware when new challengers like Google and Facebook sprung up and adopted the web for what it was and then totally ate Microsoft's lunch with it. By not looking like an OS, the web was able to differentiate itself in consumers' minds and not force comparisons to a much bigger, more mature platform until it was so entrenched it was impossible to make go away.
If you want to build a replacement for the web today, your first priority should be to think of something that millions of people will use daily. It can (and should!) be really simple initially - the Web was first used for sharing scientific papers, and then for creating WebRings of band fanpages, and then for porn, and it took 20 years or so before full webapps became viable. But thinking about it from the perspective of how you make a secure, performant, maintainable programming environment for developers is exactly the wrong approach. History is littered with projects that do exactly that and fail to get anywhere.
- davesque 9y agoI would add that anyone looking to replace the web should think about what problems the web doesn't solve. I think you could argue that this was what made the web itself successful. Mr. Berners-Lee saw that there was no system which had gained market acceptance that organized information in the way that people actually tend to organize it (which is not hierarchically). As you may have been alluding to, simply coming up with a more elegant, well-architected version of the web has no value to anyone outside of the engineering room.