3 ms·
Correct. You can only get in trouble under antitrust laws if you're a big fish in the "relevant market". Defining this term is generally where all the fighting
by gnicholas 9y ago
Correct. You can only get in trouble under antitrust laws if you're a big fish in the "relevant market". Defining this term is generally where all the fighting centers, because it makes or breaks the case. And in the case of Uber, they would argue that cabs are part of the same market. Including cabs (and not just Lyft) would make the market big enough that Uber would not be considered to have monopoly power. (Even with just Lyft, this is probably also the case.)
Source: I was a summer law clerk for the antitrust department of the CA DOJ.
- malandrew 9y agoThe market is personal transportation. Uber competes with cabs, other TNCs, personal cars, car rental, public transportation, biking, walking, etc. In a few circumstances an Uber passenger may consider only cabs and Uber when deciding how to be transported. In many many other cases, Uber passengers are considering any of the other transportation methods above. I personally often decide between an Uber or taking the bus. I don't own a car.
- otakucode 9y agoThe Sherman Antitrust Act has a great deal more in it than only defining monopoly powers. No business is permitted to engage in price-fixing, regardless of size, and that is due to that act. Many other anticompetitive practices are defined in it as well, and also apply to all businesses deemed to be engaging in 'commerce'. I'm not talking about claiming Uber is a monopoly at all, just that their actions (as described by the article) sounds to me like anticompetitive practices that are illegal under the act.