4 ms·
Everyone here seems to be sticking on the specific example of smoking, but let me generalize a bit: people who experience persecution and shaming for an activit
by derefr 9y ago
Everyone here seems to be sticking on the specific example of smoking, but let me generalize a bit: people who experience persecution and shaming for an activity they can't help but take pleasure in, tend to be very friendly—at least to those with the same "problem", but often to people with other such "problems" that have put them through the same hardships. ("Problem" in quotes, because these traits are called that by others, but almost never by the person in question.)
Which is to say: a smoker, a frequent psilocybin user, a transgendered person, a furry, and an ABDL fetishist all walk into a bar... and hang out amicably, because they've all been through shit.
(One slightly annoying thing about this, though, is that this empathy-for-outré-groups-building effect stops happening as your own group becomes less outré. Homosexuality is accepted enough today that the newest generation of gay people are growing up just as intolerant of "deviance" as everyone else.)
- jolux 9y agothis is brilliant but small nitpick it probably should be "transgender person" or "trans person" because "transgendered" has fallen out of favor for the most part
- rtpg 9y agoI agree that there's higher level of empathy, especially when you are talking with people who are accepting of the "humans are not rational, nothing means anything" philosophy that is needed to handle things like mental disorders. There does end up being a lot of suffering comparison when there's confrontation of biases though. "That might affect you sometimes, but my thing affects me all the time" or the like. I bet a lot of us would not consider "discrimination through elitism" to be a real problem but have probably seen people be scoffed at for watching Big Bang Theory or something.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jolux 9y agoThe Big Bang Theory is terrible and I have a god given right to hate people who watch it.
- flexie 9y agoSmokers have not experienced persecution. Please use this word more carefully or we dilute its meaning. The shaming of smokers has little in common with what Jews, homosexuals etc have had to endure. Smoking has not been made illegal, smokers are not imprisoned, smokers are not attacked and beaten up on streets. Smokers live in the same communities as non-smokers, are friends with non-smokers, study with no-smokers, work with non-smokers, date non-smokers, marry non-smokers. The inconveniences and at times rudeness experienced by smokers doen't constitute anything that resembles persecution.
- gras 9y agoWhat persecution of Jews has occurred in Western countries in the last 50 years? "Anti-Semitism", which has basically come to mean "any criticism or expression of dislike of any Jews or anything related to Israel"?
- throwanem 9y agoHomosexual smoker here. Can we not do oppression olympics today?
- flexie 9y agoNobody is doing Oppression Olympics. There is zero oppression of smokers, as in absolutely none.
- bogomipz 9y agoNot everyone is a native English speaker. Perhaps you could be tolerant of that?
- flexie 9y agoMe neither.
- bogomipz 9y agoWell then perhaps you can step down off your moral soapbox and stop telling people when and when it is not OK to use certain words. There is nothing in the article which even remotely trivializes past transgressions against Jews, Homosexuals or anyone else. And your implication that there is is fucking absurd.
- zhte415 9y agoTo generalise your point further generally with the experience of living away from one's home country (or, even more, one's home culture): Aliens collect with aliens. Because of a shared experience. The shared experience is being alien. Very specific but common example: A local telling a taxi driver a location "next to XYZ school that relocated a few years ago". That's pretty clear to a local. However, "on the intersection of ABC and XYZ street" would be from a non-local. Don't think of this example as in taking a taxi, or finding a place. Of the assumptions someone intimately familiar with something, assuming others are so too. That's not true. You need to think and not, on un-thought assumption, not exclude.