4 ms·
So how is Gitlab compared to GitHub?
by pmoriarty 9y ago
So how is Gitlab compared to GitHub?
- cmrx64 9y agoCompares very favorably IMO, but you'll probably want to read their marketing pages or try it yourself.
- jakebasile 9y agoIt has some features over GitHub like integrated CI and integrated Docker registry. I think the UI design is better. Merge (pull) requests and issues have some extra fancy stuff like multiple assignees and discussions on code that can be marked as competed or not. It lacks in user base (which might not matter for internal use) and performance and reliability. It can be slow and it goes down occasionally. It hasn’t been enough of a problem for my company to move back to GitHub. These observations only apply to the hosted GitLab.com, as I don’t self host I don’t know the differences there. I have both public and private personal projects as well as private company projects on it.
- fortythirteen 9y agoEnterprise Gitlab is miles beyond enterprise Github IMHO, if for nothing else just the integrated CI/CD. Trying to set up a third party enterprise CI/CD and then getting it to play with enterprise Github is a pain in the ass. With Gitlab you set up a runner instance with their CLI and you're good to go.
- jakebasile 9y agoYeah I was really surprised how easy their CI runner was to set up (I didn’t want to use the public ones for my company’s projects). Like you say it’s pretty much “install from apt, run this command”. Wonderful.
- Macha 9y agoFrom a UI POV, even enterprise Bitbucket (formerly Stash) is way ahead of Github Enterprise.
- stevekemp 9y ago> Merge (pull) requests and issues have some extra fancy stuff like multiple assignees and discussions on code that can be marked as competed or not. Perhaps that's unclear, but as of 9.5.x you can assign an issue to multiple users, but you can only assign a merge-request to one user. Being able to assign a merge-request to multiple users would be very useful..
- svesselov 9y agoWe have an issue for that here https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ee/issues/2004 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ee/issues/2004, the UX team is pushing hard to get it scheduled asap. Give the issue a thumbs up!
- mdaniel 9y agoSome of that discussion revolves around whether one wishes to be able to audit, and possibly update, these very core services in use. Comparing apples to apples may produce one outcome, comparing the liberty of eating them may produce another. I personally think GitLab is hungrier, and have some really great features, but I haven't had any contact with their support to know if something goes wrong that one can get unstuck quickly
- lloeki 9y agoOver here one of the definitive advantages of GitLab is that since we're a Ruby shop we can self-support things in case of emergency, either via gitlab-rails or gitlab-psql commands or patch right into the code to get things unstuck ASAP or even do some unsupported stuff.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt's getting better all the time. Gitlab has several large advantages over github, the major one for me is that it allows you to self-host and for companies that are conscious of their IP value and access this may sway their decision. It's not quite as polished as github yet but with their recent funding round I would expect gitlab to pick up steam and close the gap even further. For day to day use I'd say they are now at 95% feature parity or even better, and in some cases it is actually ahead.
- koolba 9y agoGitHub has an on-premises offering as well though there's no free tier.
- mdaniel 9y agoOne should also be cognizant that their on-prem lags behind the cloud offering, so don't expect to launch GitHub Enterprise and get the same features as .com
- acejam 9y agoI run and maintain a massive GitHub Enterprise installation. Features that make their appearance on .com end up in Enterprise about 3-4 months later. In an enterprise environment, I'm totally fine with GitHub testing those new features on their 15 million .com users first.
- sleibrock 9y agoI like it for the free private repos and the built-in CI that's pretty easy to use. At one point I was using Trello to manage my plans, but GitLab's issue board works just as well to my surprise! I still switch between Hub and Lab, but seeing GitLab's growth makes me smile.
- sytse 9y agoGlad to hear that our issue boards are a complete alternative, that was our intention when we launched them a little more than a year ago. They've evolved significantly since then https://about.gitlab.com/2017/08/23/issue-boards-anniversary/ https://about.gitlab.com/2017/08/23/issue-boards-anniversary...