4 ms·
America has one of the absurdly strictest set of laws for sex offenses against minors no sane politician would ever propose a relaxation in these laws So what
by jrockway 16y ago
America has one of the absurdly strictest set of laws for sex offenses against minors
no sane politician would ever propose a relaxation in these laws
So what did the other countries, that have less-strict laws, do?
(I agree that Americans are very afraid of anything sexual, but I'm not sure how this happened. Not everyone is a Puritan.)
- btilly 16y agoBack in the 90s I ran across an interesting survey. In America more people were privately concerned about excessive violence on TV than excessive sex. But most thought that their neighbors were more concerned about sex than violence. And therefore found it easier to publicly express their concerns about sex than violence. As to your question, laws and solutions vary widely by country. And other countries have their own problems. (See, for instance, the Catholic abuse scandal in Ireland.) But in general other countries have laws which serve the same purpose as US laws, however with less draconian details. For instance England and Canada have copied US legislation for registered sex offenders. However they do not seem to have implemented the sort of geographic rules on where they can live that lead to the infamous tent city under a bridge in Miami.
- ugh 16y agoSo what did the other countries, that have less-strict laws, do? It’s not a very nice answer but I think they have less direct democracies and delegate many of the nitty-gritty details of the law to experts. That’s also why there is no death penalty in Europe.
- philwelch 16y ago"That’s also why there is no death penalty in Europe." Really? My theory was always this: Frontier cultures need death penalties because they don't have the resources to keep very many people imprisoned for very long. The same is true of nomadic cultures, which explains a lot of things in the Bible. (The Old Testament has a long list of crimes, all of which are punishable with stoning. Which is sensible for a nomadic culture wandering around a region that has a lot of rocks lying around.) Vast parts of the US were a frontier culture until maybe 100 years ago (less in Alaska, more in Massachusetts). Europe has been settled for centuries. Which one do you predict would give up the death penalty first?
- ugh 16y agoAbolishment of the death penalty is very recent development (last executions: France 1977, UK 1964, Germany 1949 – arguably a special case) and public opinion is not fundamentally different between Europe and the US. There is a interesting (but expensive) book about this topic [1], from the blurb: Movements to abolish the death penalty cannot be understood without a grasp of the dynamics of public opinion on capital punishment, which is driven not by rational consideration but by what cognitive psychologists call 'social intuitions,' deeply rooted attitudes which are resistant to change. European death-penalty abolitionists quickly realized the futility of trying to change public opinion on a mass scale, and instead devised strategies to accomplish abolition despite lingering public support for the death penalty. Pointing to the importance of political structures that allowed European abolitionists to bypass public opinion, this study assesses the prospects of the 'European model' of abolition in global perspective. [1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0230231985?tag=gerjoy-21&camp=1406&creative=6394&linkCode=as1&creativeASIN=0230231985&adid=1DRWYT2134GART9GRQ6G& http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0230231985?tag=gerjoy-21&camp...;