6 ms·
"she said she’s pushing to cut “layers” in the organization and become more efficient" I hate this kind of nonsense. You can't just get rid of thousands of peo
by tootie 9y ago
"she said she’s pushing to cut “layers” in the organization and become more efficient"
I hate this kind of nonsense. You can't just get rid of thousands of people then say "efficiency" and retain full productivity. At a place like HP that's bidding on 8 or 9 figure deals, you absolutely can't function without a sizable bureaucracy.
- wmccullough 9y agoBingo. YMMV, but in my experience the majority of inefficiency is caused by middle managers who are too busy trying to "win" political capital or burn down perceived enemies. After watching HPE for a number of years my guess is that in a few months they'll add double or triple this number of layoffs to an offshore team.
- alexasmyths 9y agoSadly, there is another economic reality: most good businesses are actually very inefficient and could cut 10% without missing a heartbeat. Here's the key: when businesses develop dominance in a market, they get fat margins - and they often just 'hire'. It becomes instinctive to think that 'people create value' and so they hire. Moreover - VP's, Directors, Managers are all trying to build their status, and they 'push to hire'. I worked at a post-startup-stage high-growth company, and my VP was given directive to 'hire 100 people'. Completely not driven by business needs, or project needs, or ROI. 'Just hire'. There is sometimes good strategic reasoning for 'just staffing' up i.e. scrape all of the talent in an area way from competitors, be a 'real company' to validate the upcoming IPO etc.. but it's really perverse. Google, FB, MS - all guilty of this. Regular companies just the same. I'll bet 1/2 of finance today could be replaced by computers - or frankly nothing. 1/2 of Hedge Funds could just put their money in indexes, drop their staff and get the same results. Large successful companies often spend billions on 'new projects' that are doomed to fail - one could argue that 'failure' is part of the innovative process, yes, but it might be more efficient to invest/partner with startups. When big, lumbering companies start to wane, well, they can't afford all the graft and have to start letting go. It's an odd cycle, and it's surprisingly not as directly related to productivity as we might want to imagine. I once worked with a large internal marketing team of maybe 25 people, they did almost nothing. Nobody was really sure what they were there for. They 'did stuff'. They were smart, nice. But they were very irrelevant - and I took pains not to discount their effort, i.e. not realize that they were 'important but unrecognized' cogs in the wheel. No. They were hired 'for hiring sake' and 'worked' for the sake of 'work'. This is common. A lot of big, entrenched industries are like this.
- tootie 9y agoCertainly there's inefficiency in any human endeavor, but just cutting staff is unlikely to solve it. At least, not if you're doing it proactively to save money. Sometimes you need redundant roles just to make sure someone is paying attention to details that might get lost.
- peoplewindow 9y agoDon't you mean 100% of all hedge funds could drop their money in index funds and get better results? That's the way I interpreted the outcome of the Buffet bet.
- aswanson 9y agoThere are black swan funds like Renaissance Technologies that routinely beat the averages by 30 or more percent, year after year. You can count the number of hedge funds that do that on one hand, however.
- bjl 9y agoThat'd be true if all hedge funds were actually trying to just beat the S&P. The vast majority, however, aren't trying to do that all; they're trying to create different risk/return profiles than you get by just indexing large-cap US companies.
- microtherion 9y ago> most good businesses are actually very inefficient and could cut 10% without missing a heartbeat. Maybe so, but, being inefficient, chances that they'll identify the RIGHT 10% to cut are pretty low.
- xorcist 9y agoEspecially when a large portion of those tasked with identifying the 10% is likely part of it...
- losteric 9y ago> VP's, Directors, Managers are all trying to build their status, and they 'push to hire'. > When big, lumbering companies start to wane, well, they can't afford all the graft and have to start letting go. The thing is, they start by cutting front-line employees instead of the root cause of inefficiency: management and bureaucracy. It's best to immediately fire the managers that were hiring for the sake of status.
- rdiddly 9y agoIt's such a tired trope. Nonetheless I believe it can work that way in some cases. But in HP/HPE's case I don't believe that for a second - in their case it's just a tired trope.