3 ms·
It saddens me that for every ridiculous story like this, there is someone out there who really thought that trying to bring the case was a good idea. Some thin
by btilly 16y ago
It saddens me that for every ridiculous story like this, there is someone out there who really thought that trying to bring the case was a good idea.
Some things have improved in recent years. The incidence of bad therapy leading to false memory syndrome has been reduced, and with it the rate of false accusations. (There are also now improved odds for abused kids to be able to get information on what abuse is actually like, rather than getting detailed, unrealistic fantasies.) Others are worse. For instance in Miami the rule that sex offenders have to live at least 2500 feet from any school means that about the only place they could live was under a particular bridge. (As of April this year they have been transferred elsewhere, but which elsewhere that is I'm not sure. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julia_Tuttle_Causeway_sex_offender_colony http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julia_Tuttle_Causeway_sex_offen... for more.)
I would be the last to trivialize abuse or its very real problems. But there is a world of difference between 50 year olds going after prepubescent kids and 19 year olds who dated 16 year olds. And there is little to be gained from treating them all like lepers. Certainly less than could be gained if we, for instance, took some of the energy that goes into following up on almost certainly bogus reports and instead put it into improving the foster care system.
- danbmil99 16y ago> there is someone out there who really thought that trying to bring the case was a good idea. Really? Sounds more like there's some cynical jerk with no sense of ethics or boundaries who gets their jollies by randomly victimizing normal families with the excessive powers bestowed upon them by paranoid CYA legislation and an army of deranged ideologues who see abuse everywhere.
- jrockway 16y agoThe truth is probably somewhere in the middle: "Someone who really doesn't understand what his job is does some work in an attempt to get a promotion."
- ubernostrum 16y agoMost likely: someone whose continued employment depends on turning a certain minimum percentage of reports into criminal charges/convictions. Busting actual child abusers who have experience with the system is likely much harder than setting up innocent people who don't understand what's going on, so this would presumably be an easy case.
- ErrantX 16y agoHighly unlikely; I'm sure there are such people in the LE services - but fortunately the controls now are quite good to stop them from running amok. It sounds a lot like mad bureaucracy, incompetence and disinterest. Which, if anything, is even worse.