4 ms·
The core difficulty with that statement would be that it's wholly false. The cause of the loss of the rig and the ongoing spill was not due to unexceptional cir
by InclinedPlane 16y ago
The core difficulty with that statement would be that it's wholly false. The cause of the loss of the rig and the ongoing spill was not due to unexceptional circumstances it was due to negligence on BP's part. BP management overrode the better judgement of Transocean personnel and they ignored the established operating procedures and best practices of the industry. Had those procedures been followed there would have been no loss of life, no loss of the rig, and no spill.
Instead, BP chose to cut corners in an attempt to save a tiny amount of cost on what was likely to be a hugely profitable operation regardless. There's no excuse for that.
- stanleydrew 16y agoThe same could be said of the iPhone 4 issue as well though. It was negligent. At least one Apple engineer warned that it would be an issue and they released it anyway. No it wasn't to cut costs but it was meant to improve the marketing of the phone. Yes signal attenuation affects all phones if you hold them a certain way. But it's worse with the iPhone. So in that sense SJ is making the same kind of false statement that BP would have made with this response.
- wvenable 16y agoI'd say in the iPhone case, it's a design trade off. If you just look at the antenna alone, you might claim it's negligent but in the context of the entire device is just a minor design trade off. The idea that it's a major flaw seems pretty unwarranted. I've had phones with major flaws, this is nothing.
- nailer 16y agoNot being able to use a phone to make phone calls, when held in a normal way, is a major flaw. Other phones put their antennas in the base for a reason - the hand doesn't cover the whole area. Try as I can, I cannot replicate the problem holding an HTC Desire in a normal, comfortable grip.
- khafra 16y agoKeep in mind that your anecdotal experience with the HTC carries very little weight; I tried covering the iPhone 4 gap with my hand in areas with one bar, two bars, and three bars of coverage, and couldn't produce a visible drop--and that was specifically using an abnormal, uncomfortable grip to observe the problem.
- kujhygtfghj 16y agoAlternatively BP followed the lax standards required by the US rather than the stricter standards required in the North Sea. If it had applied all the extra european safety standards then somebody else could have extracted the oil more cheaply and would have outbid them for the rights. Then this would be a shell or esso or gulf oil disaster. Blaming the foreigners for the US safety regs is like a country with no driving tests or traffic laws blaming Ford for car accidents.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoWhat evidence is there that BP fully lived up to US safety regulations? I'm not sure that's the case but I don't have all the details. Personally, I don't view BP as a "foreign" entity, they are a trans-national corporation. Regardless, you do make a good point, if the US had as stringent of standards as required in the North Sea likely none of this would have happened.
- kujhygtfghj 16y agoI don't know, although there were items like a blowout preventer that would be required in other areas. I also don't know what the contract was, was BP in day-day charge of the rig or was that the company the rig was leased from? The capping operation was apparently being done by Haliburton! I do know that the US has 4x the industrial accident rate of Uk/Germany/Scandanavia and it's not due to foreign companies.
- nailer 16y ago'BP management overrode the better judgement of Transocean personnel ' Got a reference for that? Since Transocean owned the rig, my understanding is that most of the responsibility for how to operate the rig lay with Transocean.