5 ms·
Everyone in favor of banning certain speech based on its content should consider this article. When you open the door to banning speech based on content, the go
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Everyone in favor of banning certain speech based on its content should consider this article. When you open the door to banning speech based on content, the government will happily define something speech it does not like as "treason" or "hate speech" or whatever the favored term is.
People "shouting fire in theater" is not protected speech as a way to say that free speech protections are limited with respect to certain content. This phrase comes from Schenck vs United States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States that ruled that it was Constitutional to arrest someone for distributing anti-draft fliers. So be very careful what you wish for with regard to limits on free speech, you just might get it.
- leggomylibro 9y agoWhat are you talking about? There are obvious and practical limits on 'free speech'. In fact, the Supreme Court has unanimously upheld a "fighting words" doctrine ensuring that speech which is by its nature injurious or likely to cause breach of the peace is not protected. An excerpt from the 9-0 decision makes a pretty concise case, especially the latter part: "Allowing the broadest scope to the language and purpose of the Fourteenth Amendment, it is well understood that the right of free speech is not absolute at all times and under all circumstances. There are certain well-defined and narrowly limited classes of speech, the prevention and punishment of which has never been thought to raise any Constitutional problem. These include the lewd and obscene, the profane, the libelous, and the insulting or 'fighting' words-those which by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace. It has been well observed that such utterances are no essential part of any exposition of ideas, and are of such slight social value as a step to truth that any benefit that may be derived from them is clearly outweighed by the social interest in order and morality. 'Resort to epithets or personal abuse is not in any proper sense communication of information or opinion safeguarded by the Constitution, and its punishment as a criminal act would raise no question under that instrument.' [Cantwell v. Connecticut]" https://web.archive.org/web/20080906001323/http://laws.findlaw.com/US/315/568.html https://web.archive.org/web/20080906001323/http://laws.findl... We can argue about definitions of 'obscene', 'likely to cause a breach of the peace', etc. But to treat freedom of speech like an unassailable, all-or-nothing fundamental assumption is not helpful.
- icebraining 9y agoChaplinsky is quite outdated. It's not clear that the Fighting Words doctrine even still exists at all, but to the extent it does, it requires a physical presence inviting to an altercation by being directed at someone. Prohibitions based purely on content of speech are not constitutional. (IANAL and this is not legal advice, of course)
- adrianratnapala 9y agoIndeed, I only just read about Chaplinsky -- and it seems pretty grubby and authoritarian. Just letting cops arrest people for -issing them off. As the original article points out, the first half of the 20th century was dark time. And I'd be surprised if the present day court would rule the same way if the literal facts of the Chaplinksy case were repeated. It's an example of what I was talking about above: it's right that you aren't allowed to use your freedom of speech to incite violence. But the court in Chaplinsky extended that to protect the violent. It's a good thing that courts have been moving away from that heckler's veto. But I fear the way the politics of outrage is going, in 40 years time we will back to authoritarian norms that brought us two world wars.
- leggomylibro 9y agoYeah, the Wikipedia page on 'fighting words' goes on to describe how the doctrine has since been limited. Shouting 'you are a fascist' at a cop probably wouldn't pass muster as unprotected speech these days (if you managed to make it to court alive and weren't preaching gibberish to a large crowd that was blocking traffic at the time.) Still, speech isn't somehow inherently harmless or different from other actions that we take. It's bad to take someone's things with a knife, but I'd say that it's even worse to take someone's humanity with a word.
- ebcode 9y agoBut you can't actually take someone's humanity with a word. That's hyperbole. Knife-point robbery is not. "You cannot, sir, take from me anything that will not more willingly part withal – except my life, except my life, except my life." -- William Shakespeare
- gerbilly 9y ago>People "shouting fire in [a crowded] theater" is not protected speech But what if I want to should "Theater!" in a crowded fire? Is that protected speech?
- adrianratnapala 9y agoYes.
- tikhonj 9y agoPopehat has an article about "fire in a theater" and the court case. It's very illustrative: https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-hackneyed-apologia-for-censorship-are-enough/ https://www.popehat.com/2012/09/19/three-generations-of-a-ha...
- thephyber 9y ago> So be very careful what you wish for with regard to limits on free speech, you just might get it. The case you cited is an example that we already have limitations on free speech. That case is tragic from my perspective because I would likely try to petition people to avoid a draft, too, should it happen now. Nitpick: "shouting fire in a theater" is protected speech. It's not protected if you lie when you shout it. The risk of injury to others is possible either way, but your intent is what protects you.
- splintercell 9y ago> It's not protected if you lie when you shout it. The risk of injury to others is possible either way, but your intent is what protects you. Falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater is ALSO protected by first amendment (Supreme Court reversed their opinion in 1969 btw). I clarified more in this other comment[1]. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15307871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15307871
- splintercell 9y agoBrandenburg vs Ohio[1] overturned Schenck v United States. As it turns out that "falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater" IS protected by first amendment[2], depending upon some more complex criteria called "imminent lawless action"[3] over "Clear and present danger"[4]. Under this, distributing communist fliers is protected by the first amendment. What is not protected is Antifa's call to 'immediately' riot against their perceived enemies. The element of time is important in imminent lawless action test. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the... 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action 4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clear_and_present_danger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clear_and_present_danger